Harbourmaster stood down for orca rescue

The orca trapped in waters off Tokoroa Rock at Kennedy Bay off the Coromandel Peninsula. Photo: Fairfax NZ

A Coromandel harbourmaster who helped free an entangled orca using a Waikato Regional Council boat has been stood down from operational tasks on the water.

The breeding female had been trapped by a cray pot line for 16 hours before Whitianga harbourmaster Matthew Collicott decided to step in and help free the orca on Wednesday night.

Speaking to Fairfax, Department of Conservation spokesman Steve Brightwell says staff were notified about the entangled orca in the waters off Tokoroa Rock at Kennedy Bay at 9am on Wednesday. The original informant told DOC the orca appeared to be in a good condition.

At that stage, staff were busy and planned to go out later in the day, but by mid-afternoon conditions were unsafe and the decision was made not to risk sending staff out in the dark, so they planned to head back at 9am on Thursday, says Steve.

Throughout the day multiple calls were made to the DOC hotline and to individual conservation officers on their cellphones.

When the harbourmaster learned the orca was still trapped at 7pm, it was then he who decided to step in and help.

Orca Research Trust's Dr Ingrid Visser confirms to Fairfax Matthew and a volunteer who'd trained in whale and dolphin disentanglement, volunteered to help in the rescue and took a WRC vessel out to where the orca was trapped.

'I talked them through the protocol. They were onsite monitoring the animal and the rope became slack around the tail, so they were able to bring it alongside,” explains Ingrid

During the rescue, the pair engineered a grapnel hook out of a crowbar and hooked the line to bring the orca alongside the boat.

Ingrid says the entangled orca was being held up by another orca in its pod.

Once the rescuers established the orca wasn't trapped any further, they cut the rope free and it swam off.

'It had been entangled for 16 hours, so it was getting to the point where every breath was an issue for it. That's just inexcusable. If they hadn't have stepped in, the animal would have died.”

Ingrid is aware Matthew had now been stood down from some duties and describes the decisions as an 'absolutely disgusting display of lack of empathy”.

She also believes someone should be held to account for doing a 'despicable thing” to someone who was trying to help an animal in need.

'These guys are tasked with [knowing about] boat safety. The harbourmaster is a very experienced skipper and in a full moon and calm, there were minimal risks. [The harbourmaster] was incredibly responsible and someone who cared,” Ingrid tells Fairfax.

In a statement, Waikato Regional Council chief executive Vaughan Payne says they are checking whether any regulations were breached or operational procedures not followed during the rescue.

In the meantime Matthew, who resigned some time ago and whose final day is today, has been stood down from operational duties as inquiries continue which is expected to take some time.

- stuff.co.nz

20 comments

Good on you Mathew..

Posted on 16-12-2016 09:53 | By mutley

who has probably moved on to a more worthwhile use of his obvious common sense and initiative. I know exactly how the Dept of Conversation would have approached this matter - with inertia and bureaucratic delay - when all that was needed was someone to do the bleeding obvious. We all saw how the DoC managed "rescue" of Tama played out.


Beauracracy

Posted on 16-12-2016 10:11 | By overit

I hate it with a passion. Nimby's. Just get on with the job and rescue the orca, which is what the man did. He's a hero!


COUNCILS

Posted on 16-12-2016 10:15 | By Colleen Spiro

Crikey.....a bit reminisent of Jarron McInnes at TECT PARK, try and do some good and you lose your job over it.... COUNCILS need common sense.


Typical

Posted on 16-12-2016 10:33 | By peecee09

What absolute rubbish Waikato Regional Council. This was a critical situation and Matthew acted bravely and saved this animals life,whilst you on the other hand and DOC were all too busy crossing ts and dotting is while the orca was close to perishing. Get a grip.


Why 9am Next day?

Posted on 16-12-2016 10:59 | By cptn scully

Why on earth would D.O.C wait until 9 am next day (Thursday) to rescue this creature when it is now daylight at 5 am Four hours earlier than they were planning! Wake up you procrastinators and let Real people get on with the good work.


Despicable reaction

Posted on 16-12-2016 11:05 | By penguin

What a pathetic action from DOC in whom I have now lost faith. Couldn't agree more with mutley's comments. Imagine if emergency services adopted the same approach - wait until all protocols have been covered off before taking action. What DOC and the like need to grasp firmly is that our nation only functions by having the tens of thousands of volunteers who often risk their own safety for the good of others, including wildlife. I bet DOC would have berated Matthew if he had just sat in his boat and watched the orca slowly die. Shame on you DOC!


get a grip

Posted on 16-12-2016 11:06 | By CC8

Every bad/stupid story I have read today has involved a bureaucrat and an inane PC decision. Get a bloody grip. Doc cannot prioritise a life and death CONSERVATION decision, and some grey minibrain at WRC decides to "punish" the harbourmaster by removing his operational duties during his last two days on the job......why? ........ because he could . The only good news about this is whole story is Matthew Collicott's decision and the ensuing result. Then again if the story was slanted toward the result, that wouldn't sell newspapers.


Investigate, stand down the CEO

Posted on 16-12-2016 11:24 | By Murray.Guy

The Governance team should be investigating the CEO, perhaps having breached his 'code of conduct' requirement by his employers. It appears the CEO may have brought the Waikato Regional Council into disrepute, undermined the credibility of the Council and thereby it's effectiveness, bullied, intimidated an employee to divert attention from his and the organisations shortcomings. Yes, review the event to learn from it, enhance processes and outcomes. Clearly there are shortcomings amongst the 'pen pushers' and accolades for those actually on the water!


golly gosh

Posted on 16-12-2016 13:06 | By old trucker

Here we go again AGREE with all above the harbour marster is a HERO,10-4 out.


Appoint a Commissioner

Posted on 16-12-2016 13:10 | By Kaimai

Where are WRC Councillors? Where is the Coromandel Councillor? Noticeably quiet! Hiding behind protocol / paperwork no doubt. Councillors should be reviewing operational capacity /capabilities of the CEO. If the Councillors and the CEO can't make a competent decisions perhaps a Commissioner should be appointed.


Councils

Posted on 16-12-2016 13:33 | By phoenix

Well said Colleen Spiro. At Least some people have Longer memories than five minutes.Unfortunately there are bureaucrats whose sense of power,has acquired a We are never wrong mentality.


Immediate Rescue

Posted on 16-12-2016 13:56 | By chatter

I can guarantee that if it were a family member of one of the "bureaucrats" that was trapped or in dire stress out on the ocean, they would not be saying "oh well it can wait till morning". We all take some risk just getting out of bed... For the sake of the human race STOP being so bloody PC.


dummys

Posted on 16-12-2016 16:03 | By dumbkof2

they have to have a council meeting get a resource consent envitomental impact report and consult the local iwi before they can do anything


UNBELIEVABLE - ONLY IN BOP!

Posted on 16-12-2016 17:11 | By Papamoaner

Another dysfunctional council. Give that man an award, and instead of standing him down how about standing the absolute dork up who made that pedantic decision to punish a folk hero worth his salt in anybody's language.Is this what we have come to? The petty bureaucracy. The pious high horses of the obscene grossly overpaid. The back stabbing, the cowardly character assasinations. Our entire society is looking over its shoulder to see if we have "done something wrong" albeit OSH, PC etc. It's getting like the dark days of the Gestapo revisiting. It's an assault on our proud Kiwi culture of "drop everything and lend a hand when help is needed" What has reduced us to this level? Was it Rogernomics?


Lateral thinking required

Posted on 16-12-2016 17:46 | By Papamoaner

The second orca that was holding up the distressed orca should be prosecuted as it was clearly committing an offence by aiding and abetting a criminal in the commission of a crime.This should be investigated. We could re-create the crime scene by putting some rope around the CEO and tossing him in the drink to see if the offending orca will hold him up.


omg

Posted on 16-12-2016 19:08 | By Capt_Kaveman

oh it wasnt me who went to the rescue or said anyone could go so they suspend the best person , what a joke this country is coming to


golly gosh

Posted on 16-12-2016 21:17 | By old trucker

Agree with dumbkof2 this is true,all the PC, also agree with Chatter, its important to have a meeting about this sort of stuff, stuff everybody else, we have to have a meeting, that poor Orca ,the STRESS IT must have been under all this time,waiting for HELP,GOSH IT MUST HAVE BEEN HELL for it, and a man has LOST his job over this,i would be contacting a GOOD LAWYER over this outcome,this is really SAD, Honestly come on DOC,. we will look forward to answers soon,my 7 pennies worth,this person is a HERO doing this too help,10-4 out.


Papamoaner

Posted on 17-12-2016 18:33 | By Kenworthlogger

Love your comments. Still laughing about it...


DOC were going to take 24hrs to help?

Posted on 19-12-2016 16:58 | By BennyBenson

Seems someone there needs to be stood down, not the guy that actually got the job done.


@ Papamoaner

Posted on 22-12-2016 11:07 | By Crash test dummies

With the CEO entangled perhaps also would could see if he would float for 24 hours and perhaps see what remained. All this is about is pecking order, that the staff "were busy"? what else are they doing besides coffee and donuts? The guy showed the right spirit to get out there and get it done, certainly leaving the Orca there longer than necessary would only result in a deterioration in health and then all the full scale drama would unfold about saving it, when in fact DOC staff were the problem all along.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.