Yachties facing tickets

Six Tauranga yachties may be in trouble with the law after it is claimed they failed to get out of the path of a cargo ship entering the Port of Tauranga at the weekend.

The skippers face disqualification from placings in the race they were taking part in at the time of the incident on Sunday morning, and the marine equivalent of a ticket, a $200 fine.

The Zhe Hai 505 cargo ship.

Harbourmaster Jennifer Roberts is looking at photographic, AIS, and radar evidence after a complaint was laid by the Port of Tauranga pilot on board the Zhe Hai 505.

The pilot on board the 179m long ship carrying fertiliser says he was forced to turn to avoid a collision with the yachts competing in a race organised by Tauranga Yacht and Power Boat Club.

Before altering its course the Zhe Hai 505 made five short blasts on the horn, which officially means ‘your intentions are unclear', but the pilot says the yachts failed to take notice.

It puts them in breach of the Bay of Plenty Regional Navigational Safety Bylaw 2010 which requires small craft to stay clear of, and not impede the passage of, the commercial shipping using the port. The yachties also didn't turn on their engines to motor clear, which race rules allow them to do.

'The pilot was furious, he was most upset,” says Jennifer.

'The commodore is meeting all the skippers today and is going to talk and find out which ones it was,” says Jennifer.

'We have a group of eight, but they say there were only six, two were out of the way. I'm still narrowing down the details.”

There were 12 yachts in the race including Sniper skippered by commodore Gary Smith. His was not one of the yachts involved.

The race was the 2013 Gold Cup, a handicap race that involved the fleet leaving the harbour to round a GPS point off Motiti Island. The fleet was making its way down the channel against the last of the incoming tide with little wind.

The incident took place near the C3 channel marker on the turn from the Maunganui Roads into the Cutter Channel.

One of the yachties involved says they knew a shipping movement was near because there were two tugs standing by.

Most of the yachts were well out of the way some were a bit closer than he was, but as the tugs didn't take any action, he feels because none was needed.

Acting upon the complaint from the Harbourmaster the yacht club hierarchy has lodged a protest against the eight yachts, a protest that one of the skippers says will be vigorously defended.

From the boats' point of view the pilot over reacted says Yacht Club Commodore Gary Smith. He believes the ship would have passed the yachts safely without having to alter course.

In the past tugs have warned boats out of the way of an approaching ship, but that did not happen. He says the Harbourmaster is obliged to investigate the alleged incident because of the complaint.

6 comments

smellnose

Posted on 17-04-2013 14:34 | By smellnose

I was walking with a group around the Mount and observed the incident and I agree that the pilot overreacted as the yachts seemed to be to the left in the chanell,Did he expect to have the whole chanell to himself,


Good job...

Posted on 17-04-2013 23:00 | By EtcEtc

I hope the yachties get fined. Mind you, it's not just yachties who get too close to ships when they enter or leave our beautiful harbour. Unfortunately the pilots can't see a hell of a lot of what is in front of them as the bridge is generally at the stern of the boat......


In answer to your question

Posted on 17-04-2013 23:04 | By gremlin

<<,Did he expect to have the whole chanell to himself,>> Yes he did. These ships dont maneuver like a car. Good work Tauranga Yacht Club. Lets organise a race that involves the main shipping channels at high water so we can impede the cargo ships.


Over reaction!

Posted on 17-04-2013 23:24 | By Planesailor

What a shame the pilot "over reacted" in taking evasive action to protect the safety of the yachts and the safety of the ship and harbour. Arrogant and ignorant stance by Club Commodore Gary Smith.


Yes, over reaction

Posted on 20-04-2013 13:16 | By Mike Kuipers von Lande

There appear to be two pilots who manage to tolerate other boats in the harbour and one who freaks out if he spies another vessel. If a ship hits a small vessel the ship will be fine, the vessel and people in it won't. Most if not all of the skippers and their crew in this incident are very experienced sailors who know their boats and the channel and harbour well. The ship just needs to carry on its course. The yachts will do what they need to. And if one gets clobbered then so be it. The ship will be fine, the yacht skipper will then be at fault. What's the problem?


Port

Posted on 21-04-2013 09:46 | By Capt_Kaveman

does not own the harbour if there is recreation going on then maybe each need to tell each other i bet a ship dont go out when the power boat race is on


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.