Deck quoits and data

A Matua woman who utilised a high seas holiday cruise to gather Tauranga tourism data has uncovered what she believes to be a litany of lost marketing opportunities for the Bay of Plenty.

'I hate to say it,” says Wendy Napier-Walker. 'But we have missed the boat.”


Questioning cruiser Wendy Napier-Walker with the Tauranga brochure showing one Tauranga tour out of eight offered to passengers on the cruise boat. Photo: Tracy Hardy.

The former diplomatic corp worker spent 13 days aboard the cruise liner Dawn Princess, relaxing and compiling a passenger's perspective marketing analysis of how the Bay of Plenty is sold and received.

Wendy concludes tours are too expensive, Tauranga did not register with passengers, the city is perceived as a gateway to Rotorua and passengers are more impressed with Napier.

She also believes cruise ship passengers get dated, inaccurate and confusing information about the Bay of Plenty, Tauranga needs to be more welcoming – and the city needs a theme to sell.

Wendy cruised Auckland, Napier, Wellington, Akaroa, Port Chalmers, Fiordland and Melbourne.

As result, she believes she could make a reasonable comparative assessment of New Zealand ports of calls after questioning passengers, attending passenger briefings, absorbing passenger information and brochures and, more importantly, experiencing the Tauranga stopover.

For example, the port guides supplied to passengers on-board the liner are prepared in North America – the Tauranga map is out of date, images are blurry and obscure, there could be confusion about the locality of the shopping area at the Mount and population figures are nearly 10 years out of date.

That is just symptomatic, says Wendy.

There were nearly 2000 passengers on the cruise – most were Australian with a smattering of Kiwis and Americans. Passengers Wendy mingled with complained tours out of Mount Maunganui are too expensive.

A top-end tour like the Rotorua and Polynesian spa experience would cost an adult $299 and a child $229 and a Waimangu Valley and Rainbow Spring tour costs $239 and $169 respectively.

'Many passengers preferred to do their own thing” says Wendy.

And while they disembarked at Mount Maunganui, it's the sulphur city that was in their faces.

An information kiosk on the wharf was decked out in ‘Discover Rotorua' banners, just inside the kiosk was a stand with Rotorua brochures and other information on Rotorua.

'You could easily have missed Tauranga, the local shopping and Hobbiton, which is not even in our region,” she says. 'There was little attempt to promote Tauranga and the wider Bay of Plenty.”

Even the commercial heart of Mount Maunganui doesn't get a mention in a ‘Shopping Spotlight' publication aimed at assisting and directing shoppers before they arrive here.

And when Wendy solicited feedback from passengers, 'they said Tauranga did not register with them”.

”They were more impressed by Napier's art deco theme and port farewell featuring vintage cars, people in period costumes and a band. There was no welcome or farewell in Tauranga.”

She suggests Tauranga needs a theme to titillate tourists. 'You can't sell a secret.”

'It's all about first impressions,” she explains. 'If you're going to market something it has to be done well or it counts for nothing.”

Finally, Wendy says she'd appreciate the opportunity to share her observations with Tourism Bay of Plenty – because she believes she can help.

And for its part, Tourism BOP says it will happily meet with Wendy.

The organisation told The Weekend Sun it's aware the information the cruise ships use needs improvement for all local ports of call; and its working with Tourism NZ to improve this.

You may also like....

26 comments

Well done Wendy

Posted on 19-12-2014 09:03 | By YOGI BEAR

Confirms what all realised who reside outside of Tourism BOP, the hopeless bureaucratic monopoly that exists for the sole egotistical benefit of its over paid, ticket clipping muffit brains who get paid regardless of result, effort, consequence.


@wendy

Posted on 19-12-2014 10:14 | By penguin

Hardly any surprises here. Tauranga tourism has rested on its laurels for decades assuming that the rest of the world would see the area through the same rose-tinted glasses. Well, it hasn't happened and it won't happen until the proverbial digit is extracted and a solid marketing plan is formulated. I recall a tourism forum held in Baycourt where a representative from Tourism NZ stated that Tauranga had no 'centre” and Cameron Road was just like a long billboard. Not a lot has changed. We have walking tracks, parks, adventure activities, cafes and restaurants. Shopping is ho hum but, apparently, cruise tourists don't spend much on shopping, anyway. Napier has got it right. The tourists feel a bit special with bands, vintage cars and so on. What do we offer? Wharf sheds and a kiosk. They are certain to get tourists buzzing - yeah right!


Tourism BOP ...

Posted on 19-12-2014 10:24 | By chancer

Tourism BOP has been 'working with' NZ Tourism on this ever since cruise ships started arriving @ The Mount. Why not send a small delegation of our own people directly to the cruise ship publicity people who operate offshore. Could be a wise investment but first Wendy is right, we need to have something to promote.


Finally!

Posted on 19-12-2014 12:28 | By sojourner

Finally someone who can speak from experience what should be clear to all. And yes, Tauranga is too expensive and so is the rest of New Zealand. There isn't a tourist who doesn't say so. I'm not convinced Tauranga needs a theme, a gimmick like Napier. There is plenty to promote without it, but promoted it needs to be.


What are u known for

Posted on 19-12-2014 13:16 | By michael_l_c

When I think of Tauranga I think of Kingfish. You can guarantee some of those on board would love the chance to catch some. There must be plenty of other ideas from the locals.


Tourism BOP

Posted on 19-12-2014 13:17 | By dstewart

These people are paid to promote the area. One wonders why they have done so little for so long and got away with it.


Re Tourism BOP's Response

Posted on 19-12-2014 13:30 | By Scrotney

Typical - Tourism BOP suggests sending a small delegation to meet the off-shore cruise ship publicity people. No doubt travelling business class & stopping in flash hotels! The answer is here in Tauranga - surely? Send them an email!


Rastus

Posted on 19-12-2014 15:48 | By rastus

Yogi Bear has it all summed up - having travelled extensively and taken advantage of organized day trips (extras) all over the world I can agree that we need to get off our backsides and put some real effort into a service (trade) that is so full of promise and is only waiting for a good entrepreneur to exploit that potential - Thirty years ago I would have jumped at the chance - too long in the tooth now!


So

Posted on 19-12-2014 17:05 | By nerak

TBOP is ‘working with Tourism NZ'??? Are they incapable of acting autonomously? Gravy train comes to mind, keep nodding, keep hauling in the $$. Fair go, TBOP, get off your butts and promote Tauranga, organise/update the necessary. Take a leaf out of Coromandel's book, years ago they promoted the area well outside NZ, and it paid dividends, streets went from almost empty in off season months to being pretty alive today. But of course, that needs brains, and doing something. Wendy, push, and push hard. A morning at McLarens Park, with the tea kiosk OPEN, comes to mind. Or TePuna Quarry Park. Or a hangi lunch just outside town...


Opportunity Knocks Part 1

Posted on 19-12-2014 18:10 | By Stella535

More of the same old... Tauranga is slowly but surely loosing its heart, and for cruise passengers, Tauranga is known for little more than a beach holiday spot and gateway to Rotorua's wide variety of attractions and activities. There are also many passengers whom just 'save' on Tauranga for the charm of Napier. Tauranga should be, and could be a stand alone DESTINATION with its very own unique character and defining attractions (in addition to the Mount, beaches, parks and reserves.) For years the Tauranga City Council, Tourism Bay of Plenty and a host of other peripheral organisations and associations have continued to bleat their own praises over 'stats' and 'numbers' whilst Tauranga's future tourism development opportunities are not addressed. Many Tauranga businesses continue to struggle with a global downturn in tourism spend, and are also subjected to continuous controls, regulations and red tape... see part 2


Opportunity Knocks Part 2

Posted on 19-12-2014 18:26 | By Stella535

We are now learning a valuable lesson that it is not just about how many thousands of passengers are onboard visiting cruise ships, but more importantly about what it is that these passengers seek to experience and enjoy during their port of call. Are they engaged in wanting to explore Tauranga? Are there things worth doing and places worth visiting in Tauranga? Is the valuable tourism dollar being spent in Tauranga? Wendy's first hand experience holds the answer, and is yet another account of the dismal failure to build Tauranga into a stand alone tourism destination. Shore tours are more expensive than ever thanks to local operators increased operating costs, including having to pay commissions to Tourism Bay of Plenty. What is it exactly that operators receive in return - as according to Wendy's and other cruise passengers accounts, there is little being done for Tauranga... see part 3


Opportunity Knocks Part 3

Posted on 19-12-2014 18:49 | By Stella535

We need to grow Tauranga tourism in a free, fair and sustainable manner, with simple, easy to live with controls that encourage unique tourism products and further the rapid development of Tauranga attractions. There are solutions and ways to build Tauranga as a stand alone destination, but as stated by so many others in the local tourism industry, our cities network of organisations are just not willing to discuss, develop or implement meaningful change - let alone admit that they have made any mistakes or miscalculations. So for now the cruise ships keep coming and Tauranga will fly the flags of Rotorua, play second fiddle to Napier, and fleece the cruise passengers for as long as we can. So sad, when TAURANGA has so much potential. Opportunity has been knocking for years - it's about time we opened the door and welcomed it in. Merry Christmas to all.


Amateur opinion

Posted on 19-12-2014 19:01 | By Hawaii Five-0

Going on a cruise and chatting to other passengers doesn't make Wendy an expert in tourism or marketing. She shows her naivety regarding the cost of tours booked on board - these are organised by huge international cruise companies who add a healthy profit. Tourism BOP has no control over their pricing. Canny cruisers don't book on board - similar tours are available for much less on the wharf at the i-PORT booking centre. These tours are with local operators screened by Tourism BOP, so good for our economy. Wendy must have also missed the friendly ambassadors on board and on the wharf who distribute up-to-date maps and info. Tauranga is the closest port for Rotorua and it's understandable that first-time visitors want to visit this premier tourist destination. Tauranga will pick up repeat cruisers, and some passengers may return on non-cruise holidays, spending longer and therefore more tourism dollar


Another amateur opinion....

Posted on 20-12-2014 09:54 | By Jimmy Ehu

so Hawaii Five-O, why then is the Tauranga C.B.D not seething with visitors, when 3 x years ago all the inane entities where throwing pie-charts/graphs of all sorts of number predictions, action was sort of expected.... NOT!!! same old city of missed opportunities still, and "bo****ks to your repeat visitor statement.


@Hawaii Five-0

Posted on 20-12-2014 11:22 | By penguin

I think it is you who needs to grasp the REALITY of the situation and deal to your naivety. Wendy undertook what many credible organisations do and that is to undertake informal and unbiased surveys. The informal data gained from these has as much validity as expensive, business-based ones. Well done Wendy for using your cruise time to highlight the issues.


Quoits interrupted

Posted on 20-12-2014 11:57 | By Annalist

Most people go on a cruise to relax and enjoy. I hope they didn't mind Wendy's survey. To clear things up for her. The reason cruise ships dock in Tauranga is that it is closer to Rotorua than docking in Auckland. For all the hype about Tauranga, the historic village, elms and shopping, many tourists of course want to see Rotorua because of the unique boiling mud, geysers etc. The cruise ships offer tours that are expensive because they make extra money which usually compensates for cheap cruise prices?? Tours are expensive but it's the same everywhere from Tauranga to Timbuktoo. And if tourists cruises are really made by a brass band and costumes Wendy could take a trumpet or to down to the port and make their day. I actually feel a bit sorry for tourism BOP perhaps feeling obliged to show interest in armchair experts?


Professional opinion 1

Posted on 20-12-2014 14:52 | By Hawaii Five-0

Cruise companies select which tours can be booked on board and set the price, just as they control content of on-board publications. They are massive international companies and trying to influence them is like trying to get Fonterra to drop the milk price. In the scheme of things, TBOP is a minnow and Tourism NZ isn't much bigger. No-one can access passengers before they disembark as cruise companies don't want anyone else taking a slice of the pie. TBOP can only try to help local operators mop up passengers who don't take the tours offered on-board. Luckily many passengers, especially repeat cruisers, now realise the tours offered by cruise companies are a rip-off and are willing to wait and book cheaper tours on-shore, or book online before arrival. There is an info and booking centre right in the port for this purpose, with plenty of Tauranga tour options available


Professional opinion 2

Posted on 20-12-2014 14:55 | By Hawaii Five-0

(..continued) Cruise companies control everything, right down to whether there is a welcome (some cruise lines arrange a Maori welcome at Tauranga, some don't). If they offer a paid shuttle to the city (more money for them) they don't want passengers to know about free shuttles or cheap public transport. Cruise ship dollars are a bit of myth. Most cruises are cheap holidays and passengers generally aren't big spenders. I've been down the Mount and seen them rushing back for lunch because it's included in the fare so no money spent in cafes. TBOP is probably doing its best to work with these giant companies, and I'm picking it only has a small budget since ratepayers don't want to cough up more. You can't expect economic miracles, but guess it's better to have the ships here than not. If TBOP gets too demanding, they might just pull out altogether.


Unique Attractions?

Posted on 20-12-2014 16:01 | By Stella535

Rotorua does indeed have its unique thermal attractions, at let's remember that TBOP represents all of Bay of Plenty, not only Tauranga. But, Wendy's original observations remain as to what does TAURANGA offer cruisers in the form of day tour attractions /experiences that are exciting, enjoyable, memorable and uniquely different from other ports of call? I still hear from cruise passengers' of past reminiscing about the day they drove around Tauranga and the coast in rented Porsche/Ferrari sports cars, that used to be on offer at the Port of Tauranga Gates. Although this is not quite what I and many others have in mind, this unique experience was very different from the norm, and left a lasting impression of their Tauranga port of call - even if it came in the shape of a topless, German/Italian, wind in the hair sports car experience. Another small reminder of opportunities wasted.


@Hawaii Five-0

Posted on 20-12-2014 17:01 | By penguin

Notwithstanding anything you have noted in your long discourse (much of which is common knowledge), Wendy's survey still has validity in its own right. If nothing else, it serves to highlight some of the points you have made. There is work to be done and it doesn't just relate to cruise ships. In many brochure displays in NZ, Tauranga sits as poor cousin to Rotorua. Done properly, aggressively promoting local experiences (other than Rotorua's mud pools) could be a draw-card for Tauranga. Putting it into the too-hard basket is a cop-out and simply submitting to the bullying tactics of big companies.


TBOP does NOT represent Rotorua, just looks that way

Posted on 20-12-2014 23:10 | By Murray.Guy

NZ5 says, "....let's remember that TBOP represents all of Bay of Plenty, not only Tauranga." Wrong. TBOP does NOT represent all of the Bay of Plenty. Rotorua is a separate, outside of TBOP, and Tauranga City ratepayer are by far the most significant contributor to their play money.


Let's get real about Tauranga attractions

Posted on 21-12-2014 11:37 | By BullShtAlert

I love living in Tauranga but to suggest that tourists somehow prefer to stay here and see either the Tauranga shops, the historical village, or a salt water hot pool, is missing the point. Just as most tourists wouldn't go to France and not see the Eiffel Tower, most tourists won't come to NZ and not see boiling mud and geysers. They happen to be in Rotorua. We do ok with cruise passengers who happen to stay here and relax. No need for costumes or farewell bands at the wharf. Mind you, if bull#### was music many of the commenters would be a brass band!


Last post

Posted on 21-12-2014 12:00 | By Hawaii Five-0

Destination Rotorua is a far more powerful, better-funded organisation than TBOP so can market more aggressively. Best to work with them not against them. Surveys depend on who, what, and how you ask and should cover many people off different ships. I have spoken to thousands (no kidding) of visitors and most have a favourable impression of Tauranga/Mount and attractions. Family members coming through the i-PORT said it was a great service. But I've also heard souvenir shop owners whinging loudly about BOP tourism to cruise tourists who looked uncomfortable - how embarrassing. Passengers can get information and/or book diverse experiences at the i-PORT or non-cruisers at the i-SITE. These include Tauranga and the Mount, McLaren Falls, Katikati, kiwi-fruit, honey, cycling, helicopter, aerobatic and scenic flights, sailing, arts, surfing, fishing, shopping and much more. Classic cars can be hired (there's often a limo waiting at the port). Plenty to d


Hawaii Five-O is right

Posted on 21-12-2014 18:32 | By Annalist

The cruise ships control the info and tours presold to passengers, including the price. Notable local moaners about everything need to get over themselves and be grateful that all business ratepayers are forced to pay towards BOP tourism promotion. If they can't stop whining, then cut the ratepayer subsidy fullstop. Perhaps some retailers are peeved because they can't deliver tourists to their shop front door to buy assorted tourist stuff at marked up prices?


Some good points made

Posted on 17-01-2015 10:18 | By Ngaere

Some good points made.


Its sometimes hard to believe

Posted on 17-01-2015 10:23 | By Ngaere

Its sometimes hard to believe people have to pay to go on holiday to a place we live and see every day.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.