Another protest against SH2 barriers

People opposed to median barriers on SH2 are planning to protest along the highway on Tuesday, July 16.

Rain or shine, State Highway 2 residents are ready to protest once again for their right to turn into the side roads.

Median barriers are being installed as part of the SH2 Waihī to Ōmokoroa safety improvements project for the NZ Transport Agency.

A spokesperson for the roading agency says the aim of the barriers is to prevent head-on crashes, save lives and prevent serious, life-long debilitating injuries.

“We acknowledge these barriers can make life a little bit more challenging for some road users, however we believe the risk of not making it home altogether is much worse,” says NZTA in a statement provided to SunLive.

“Research shows where they are installed, median barriers typically reduce the number of people killed or seriously injured in crashes by 75 per cent.”

Despite this, residents opposed to the barriers are planning to protest on SH2 on Tuesday, July 16.

From 8am they will protest along Sharp Rd and the SH2 intersection no matter the weather, they say via a group chat on Facebook.

“This will be quite a big event, so please come along and show how you feel and think about the proposed median barriers,” says the road representative in the email they sent out to all side road residents.

“Tell your family, neighbours and friends.”

Residents have also been in contact with Coromandel MP Scott Simpson in the hope he can help with their plight.

In response to an email from Lisa Anderton, Simpson says he simply does not “understand NZTA’s decision to proceed”.

“They are the decision maker, so it is NZTA we have to convince.”

Lund Rd resident Gino de Graaf and former Western Bay of Plenty District councillor and Work Rd resident Mike Williams spoke on Breakfast with Paul Brennan on Reality Check Radio to talk about the installation of median barriers on SH2, and how the inability to make right turns is likely to cause havoc for local road users.

“We’re not opposed to a centre barrier – we have been, for years, asking NZTA to be sensible and allow right-hand turns into the side roads that they are cutting off,” says Mike. “We have at least eight side roads that will be closed, and those roads will have near on 1000 households on them.

“The argument that NZTA have pitched is that we must have no gaps to save lives. But in reality, the gaps have very little affect on the outcome of saving lives,” says Mike, in his opinion.

The NZTA spokesperson says: “To achieve the greatest safety benefit – there needs to be as few gaps between the median barriers as possible. However, to ensure the road remains fit for purpose for residents we have given careful consideration to the placement of turnaround bays, ensuring the distance between them is reasonable and enables the community to remain connected.”

“This road SH2 has had more than $100 million spent on it in the past four years where every intersection has been improved in right in and right out and they’ve been widened and the speed limit has been dropped to 80km an hour,” says Gino.

“NZTA have constantly painted us as being pained by inconvenience when inconvenience is not the main factor in the equation. They’ve painted us as spoilt brats that don’t want to travel further but really, it’s fundamentally a disconnect and a huge amount of arrogance displayed by the entity NZTA to not compromise.

“Boy, have we tried the last two or three years to get any kind of compromise or shifting in thinking and there’s been none.

“We’ve tried the official line and we’ve been trying to get some reasoning but now we’re protesting and we’re putting signs up. We’re constantly working to get information and get other people on board to help us with this. So, it’s kind of come out of our hands now, we the local people are going to act out in the legal fashion to make themselves be heard,” says Mike.

“We’ve approached politicians; our local politician has been quite helpful in trying to get some common sense, but I have approached Simeon Brown on several occasions, I’ve had one automatic reply but nothing else,” says Gino.

“I have tried to arrange a meeting with him and Simon Bridges who’s the chairman of NZTA but to try and get an audience with those guys is absolutely impossible it seems at the moment, and we just don’t know what our next moves are, except for people taking action into their own hands and being disruptive.”

For more information, visit the ‘Flexible road safety barriers’ page on the NZTA website: www.nzta.govt.nz/roads-and-rail/road-engineering/road-safety-interventions/flexible-road-safety-barriers.

 

9 comments

Convenience over Safety

Posted on 12-07-2024 07:00 | By Ghost

Oh, the joy of convenience over safety! Because who needs boring old safety when we can all just live on the edge, right?
Let's replace those pesky seat belts with cozy hammocks in our cars. I mean, who doesn't love a good nap while driving? And forget about helmets on motorcycles — windblown hair is the new safety standard!
Who needs those annoying warning labels on hot coffee cups? Let's make 'em nuclear-hot and really keep people on their toes. And don't even get me started on those ridiculous guardrails on cliffs — free-falling is just another form of extreme sport, right?
So here's to convenience! Because life's too short to worry about little things like safety, common sense, or, you know, staying alive. Let's embrace chaos and see where it takes us!


Safety!

Posted on 12-07-2024 08:56 | By Wigan

Oh Ghost, your wit just makes me want to throw up!
Imagine they put one of these barriers across the end of your street and you had to drive an extra 7KM just to get in or out.
Even worse, your house caught fire & the extra 7KM the fire truck had to drive made the difference between your young child being rescued or burning to death.
Common sense is what is being asked for not out & out stupidity


Wigan

Posted on 12-07-2024 10:06 | By Shadow9

Wigan, im happy people like you exist! Well said!


@Ghost

Posted on 12-07-2024 12:31 | By morepork

I enjoyed your post but, in this case, your sarcastic hyperbole is misplaced.These residents have a serious problem and they seem to have no redress. Nobody is listening because Authorities don't HAVE to. I can understand their frustration and anger. Words like "safety" have different meanings for different people and it is time we addressed it at national level.


This situation higlights a serious flaw in our governance.

Posted on 12-07-2024 12:40 | By morepork

There needs to be a mechanism (maybe an indepent arbiter, Ombudsman, or even independent government commission of investigation,) that can be invoked when an Authority cannot reach a compromise to accommodate a community's objection to their proposed plan.
Both sides here have a position, but the gap is too wide for a sensible and acceptable compromise, apparently. Because the Law is the way it is, an Authority can simply override a community, and that is what they are doing.
Even if they were "right", that is no way to implement Democratic government. We definitely need to do better than that and it's time that a generic solution to this kind of situation was addressed by Government.


Make all drivers wear helmets

Posted on 12-07-2024 12:59 | By Aah well

Having even temporary road closures currently around our house is frustrating enough. Can't imagine tolerating it being permanent.


Emergency services

Posted on 12-07-2024 14:55 | By katikatinudist

What have the fire, Police, Or Ambulance service said on this matter?


@ katikatinudist

Posted on 15-07-2024 12:22 | By Yadick

You raise a VERY good point. After all, I'm sure that NZTA having completed their due diligence would have consulted with emergency services . . .
Perhaps Sunlive could look into this and put their findings into print.


Safety barriers

Posted on 20-07-2024 15:57 | By LeighM

Safety barriers are dangerous. A centre barrier & a shoulder one, add a crash or a breakdown & the road is blocked, no access for emergency vehicles. The opposing lane will have to be used until the lane is cleared. Also barrier repair crew will block 1 lane for repairs which could take a day or 2. From Levin to Foxton 1 counted 5 incidents where the barrier was damaged. That’s in about 16ks. There has been absolutely no thought by NZTA into this, a disaster waiting to happen.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.