News presenter Peter Williams describes Māori language week as tokenism towards a beautiful sounding language.
In an opinion piece for TV One, Peter says he applauded the efforts made by both Pākehā and Māori television and radio presenters for trying to get audiences involved in te reo Māori.
New presenter Peter Williams asks, should the national anthem be sung only in Māori? File.
'But at the end of another seven days of endless kia ora and morena and nau mai, and thankfully some other phrases as well, why do I feel as if it's just more tokenism towards this beautiful sounding official language of Aotearoa.”
Peter says after 41 years of Māori Language Week it was time to take two significant steps – make all motorway signs bilingual and to drop the English verse of the New Zealand national anthem.
The presenter admits it will be an expensive task but says it's been done overseas with success.
'If Wales, Ireland and Canada can have their main traffic signs in two languages, why can't we?
'A start could be made with the under construction Waikato Expressway. Inside five years, there'll be at least a four-lane highway from north of Auckland to south of Hamilton.
'There's still a whole lot to be completed but as there'll be many exits to signpost along the way, couldn't we at least make a start by displaying ara ki waho to indicate an exit?”
The news veteran says he would also like to see the national anthem sung in Māori only.
'If we leave the English verse off the New Zealand Anthem at high profile ceremonial occasions, like rugby tests, we'll encourage all New Zealanders to a) learn the Maori [sic] words and b) sing them often.”
Peter recalled the time musician Hinewehi Mohi sang the Māori version of the national anthem at the 1999 Rugby World Cup at Twickenham.
'It sent shockwaves around the thousands of All Black fans there, let alone the TV audience at home, who were just not expecting the bi-lingual version at such a game. There were, of course, howls of outrage around the country.
'As the ONE News reporter who covered the match and highlighted the first public performance of the Maori [sic] Language Version, I was chastised by both sides of the argument.
'One, for highlighting something that would obviously be a one-off and the other for not suggesting this is the way it should be.”
Eighteen years on and the anthem is now sung in both Māori and English at public occasions.
'It's been great, but now it's time to take the next step. I was at the All Blacks – Wales test in Dunedin a few weeks ago and in the pre match ceremonies it occurred to me just how long the two verse Te Reo – English version takes.
'Let alone of course, how the crowd pretty much mumbles Te Reo until the change in key after the last line Aotearoa,” says Peter.
'Before that had been the Welsh anthem, entirely in the Welsh language and with words that are unpronounceable and unintelligible to most of us, but still with such a strong melody and sung with pride by the Welsh supporters at the stadium that night.
'And I'd wager that for most of those supporters, the only time they ever speak or sing more than a word or short phrase of their national language is when they burst into some Mae henwlad fy nhadau yn annwyl I mi. So don't we have an identical situation here?”
Peter says a language only spoken in this country making a song with memorable, lilting lyrics and a familiar tune would be an experience unique for New Zealand at public ceremonies and sports events.
'Besides – do we really need to warble out lines anymore about ‘entreating our voices' and being guarded ‘from shafts of strife and war'?”



11 comments
plenty disagree
Posted on 17-07-2016 08:05 | By Captain Sensible
There are plenty of people who don't agree with the TV presenter. To get a job with TVNZ, one must be very PC and it seems so far, almost totally ignorant of real NZ history.
safe assumption
Posted on 17-07-2016 08:33 | By Fonzie
That Peter williams is a fluent Maori speaker then? Or is he like the Maori King who can't speak the language?
mayori
Posted on 17-07-2016 08:47 | By dumbkof2
some place names would need a signpost 3 m long to fit in and the maori version should be dropped from the national anthem
anthem
Posted on 17-07-2016 08:52 | By dumbkof2
peter williams yopu have just gone way down in my estimation. i always thought you had much more sense than that
Ridiculous
Posted on 17-07-2016 09:01 | By Jitter
The National Anthem was origionally written in English by a European. If needs be it must be sung in both English and Maori. Peter Williams as a "respected" media presenter should look at the wider picture. In the future Asian and Pacifica people in NZ will outnumber Maori so all needs must be catered for. Asian, Pacifica and English language weeks should also be instituted. English because many students leaving secondary school, public figures, media presenters and newspaper reporters cannot read, write or speak English correctly. As a multi cultural society, using Williams logic, road signs should also be in an Asian and Pacifica language.Has he any idea what that would cost ?
Keep both languages
Posted on 17-07-2016 09:49 | By Blessed
What should be done is encourage people to pronounce maori words properly. This is the respectful thing to do. Aotearoa/ New Zealand has our own unique culture that we SELL to the world, this is what many tourists come to see, YET, the option to learn and speak maori is NOT available in all schools. Maori is Native and endemic to NZ so the option should be there to learn the language all over the country. Start with teachers, have them be able to correctly pronounce maori words and then they can assist and encourage students to correctly pronounce words so that when students grow up, they know to say the word right, its easier than English. Don't believe in forcing people to become fluent, but what is the problem with pronouncing maori names properly? Why don't you do it?
Overit
Posted on 17-07-2016 11:47 | By overit
I like the 2 language National Anthem. As for road signs etc in Maori, the pc brigade are at it again. Might as well resign ourselves to it, it will get shouved down our throats.
Overit
Posted on 17-07-2016 11:55 | By overit
There is a Maori Channel & Te Reo if you want all things Maori flick over there.
All anti-Maori
Posted on 17-07-2016 22:53 | By johndoe
You lot reflect the new Tauranga, racist, ancient, boring with nothing better to do. What sad lives.You need to hope its not a brown hand that feeds you your broth in the exit homes.
@ johndoe
Posted on 18-07-2016 09:07 | By Captain Sensible
Ahhh yes, disagree with something maori and that makes one a sad racist. Thanks johndoe for keeping up the tried and tested predictable MO of the 'everything-maori-is-good' brigade.
Disagree
Posted on 18-07-2016 15:01 | By Jitter
These comments are not racist or anti Maori. As a truly multicultural society we must include all cultures in decision making no matter what the decision is. "johndoe" is incorrect and biased himself in his comments as he is showing that he is against our multicultural society. Most NZers are dead against this fight to continue with a bicultural society when we are obviously now multicultural.
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.