Church should not support claim

Why is the Anglican Church apologising to a couple of Tauranga sub-tribes for selling its land to the Crown in 1867 "without seeking their agreement"? There was no need to seek anybody's agreement since the Church Missionary Society had bought the land outright by two purchases in 1838 and 1839 – transactions that were ticked off by Governor Hobson's Land Commission after 1840 as conveyances that had been made freely between willing sellers and a willing buyer.

Either the Church is plain dumb or it is colluding with the tribal elite to deceive the public.

At the Anglican Synod in May 2018, the Church said that it would support an application to the Waitangi Tribunal by the Ngai Tamarawaho and Ngati Tapu to get some ‘compensation' (from the taxpayer) for this ‘grievance' that historically does not exist.

As we wrote in our recent book Gate Pa and Te Ranga: The Full Story "If the Anglican Church genuinely wants to create harmony and integrity in society, it should not be misrepresenting historical truths in support of a bogus claim for a non-existent grievance that has as its object the further enrichment of the tribal elite at the expense of the taxpaying public".

J McLean and J Robinson, Wellington.

You may also like....

2 comments

Thank you for bringing this to our attention!

Posted on 02-11-2018 16:47 | By crazyhorse

I'm gobsmacked to hear something like this could happen, so this land was sold "square and fair" and now Iwi are asking for compensation, I wonder if this double dipping is going on anywhere else, I truly hope not because that would be classed as fraud, and the government or waitangi tribunal "wouldn't let that happen!".


This is nothing new

Posted on 03-11-2018 14:22 | By Centurion

It is very clear that that so-called 'grievances' based on recently manufactured oral history are given precedence over the actual facts recorded at the time. Is it fraudulent? May be, maybe not. But it is certainly very politically correct to bow down to any demand, no matter how outlandish It is. Welcome to the 'partnership'.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.