Staff harassment costs VTNZ

‘Get your udders out' is a statement Vehicle Testing New Zealand, Mount Maunganui, senior manager Keith Johnston likely regrets after it cost the business a compensation pay out.

The Employment Relations Authority has awarded Katherine Spakes $10,500 in distress compensation and eight months in lost earnings after she was unfairly dismissed from VTNZ.


VTNZ in Mount Maunganui.

She worked there for five years as a customer services representative, but lost her job in 2011 when she stopped showing-up for work owing to harassment.

The harassment was by senior manager Keith Johnston; he pulled her hair and made derogatory comments.

These actions distressed Katherine, who stopped showing-up for work, leading to her dismissal.

She complained to the Employment Relations Authority that she was unfairly dismissed.

The ERA released its ruling on February 3 with it reciting the main events that led to the dismissal.

Trouble began in August 2010 when Katherine's ponytail was pulled and her back touched by Keith.

This was followed in March 2011 by a verbal harrassment when Katherine was talking on the phone at work about a ‘cowgirl themed' hen's night.

In the call she explained she was not going to be dressing up for the party when Keith entered the office and overheard part of the conversation.

Following the call, Katherine says Keith said: 'You don't need a costume anyway Kate, you can go along mooing. You know, like a cow. Then you can get your udders out.”

The comment was traumatic for Katherine, who stayed at home the following day and then lodged a formal written complaint with VTNZ.

Katherine began to suffer medically due to the stress of the incidents, and sought advice from her doctor.

She was signed off work for two weeks due to anxiety, lack of sleep and depression resulting from the incidents.

She was also examined by a VTNZ nominated doctor, who granted a further two weeks sick leave.

After a meeting with Katherine, VTNZ deemed the complaint was resolved and that she would return to work.

When Katherine refused to return to work, and after three day's absence, which was covered by a medical certificate, VTNZ informed her if she did not return to work immediately her employment would be terminated.

This occurred and led to Katherine's complaint to the ERA.

The ERA has found that Katherine was unfairly pressured to return to work and that VTNZ had not resolved all of her complaints as no outcome was achieved regarding them.

VTNZ denied that Katherine had been unfairly dismissed and said her employment was ended by an ‘abandonment clause in her individual employment agreement'.

Katherine, a mother of two, hopes to put the incident behind her.

'I am pleased with the authority's decision, but only wish I had spoken up more loudly and clearly.

'It is important to speak up loud and clear, and if you're not confident, to ask someone for help.

'I should have been able to rely on VTNZ to have dealt with (the) inappropriate behaviour, but because of a situation with a former colleague and her dismissal, and the boss in question being moved sideways, I had no trust in the HR department.

'I worked for VTNZ for five years and enjoyed my job; it was a very unfortunate set of circumstances.

'I still attend counselling and think often of my former workplace and dread running into my old boss.”

Tauranga lawyer Warwick Reid says cases such as Katherine's are difficult to prove and advises any women suffering from any form of harassment in the workplace to speak up.

'Cases of reimbursement for economic loss as a result of psychological injury are exceedingly rare in New Zealand.”

VTNZ has until March 3 to appeal the decision.

9 comments

Balanced?

Posted on 14-02-2012 12:10 | By bigted

Whilst her manager's comments made were clearly unwise, consider if the sexes were reversed in this case of office politics. Would/should the male have taken such a stance? Hmmmm...


should know better

Posted on 14-02-2012 15:01 | By dms63

A "SENIOR MANAGER" should know better. Whats his problem?....Does he not like women?? No one should be in a management position if they can't control themselves. They are suppose to lead by example. If VTNZ are going to keep Mr Johnston in a management position (anywhere) they should send him on a management refresher course, at the VERY LEAST.


tomtom

Posted on 14-02-2012 18:52 | By tomtom

like Kathrine said 'it is important to speak up loud and clearly'.the sexes weren't reversed, and I'm sure any man thus treated, would be afforded the same opportunity before the ERA.She spoke up, and now has been forced to leave, and the 'BULLY' is still at VTNZ! call that justice?


Behaviour

Posted on 14-02-2012 20:00 | By CNS

In response to bigted, these comments [and actions] weren't "unwise", they're intolerable. This so-called Manager should be absolutely ashamed of his behaviour. Shame on you. It is of no difference whether sexes were reversed in the circumstances. You need to rethink your values to even consider circumstances where such behaviour in the workplace might be considered acceptable. Grow up.


CNS

Posted on 14-02-2012 22:09 | By TgaBornandBred

You are 100% right. The manager should be ashamed, as should VTNZ for allowing him to keep his job!


@ Bigted

Posted on 14-02-2012 22:26 | By Colleen Spiro

I would have wrapped something else of his around my hand VERY TIGHTLY and see how he liked it. Are you suggesting a man would have enjoyed the same actions from a woman.....


Experience it

Posted on 14-02-2012 23:45 | By tibs

Go and get a WoF there, you might soon get to feel what's wring with the place. The attitude at the top leaves a little to be desired and they act as if they're a law unto themselves. Better still, get your WoF elsewhere at an MTA member, they're the garages who "own" this lot and struggle to survive as VTNZ would like to stop them issuing WoF and CoFs.


Maybe, just maybe

Posted on 15-02-2012 07:55 | By KiwiSteve

The manager should mooove to anudder branch of VTNZ Possibly a branch in the Waikato, so that he can support the Mooloos. In all seriousness, this is an udder disgrace. I think I've milked it all I can.


Much Ado about Nothing

Posted on 15-02-2012 09:08 | By SpeakUp

Shows that bovines have no humor. And for the opportunistic PC brigade: get a life.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.