Buried pumice delays Bay Link flyover construction

Construction on the highway project began in 2017. Photo: Daniel Hines/SunLive.

One of the country's most expensive stretches of new highway just got more costly - and further delayed - by buried pumice that wasn't spotted despite scores of ground tests.

The 2km stretch of the Bayfair to Baypark upgrade on State Highway 2 was already costing $70 million per kilometre - two to three times more than usual.

But three years after construction began in 2017, the New Zealand Transport Agency Waka Kotahi has realised the ground is not stable enough for what it is building, after a pumice layer was uncovered during work.

That forced an ongoing, major redesign and related changes to construction methodology and to the rest of the Bay Link programme.

NZTA says new equipment must be brought in, under a new contract, to begin building new flyover foundations, probably in November.

Tauranga Mayor Tenby Powell is surprised and frustrated.

He was not aware of the issue until RNZ told him on Wednesday.

"That is very frustrating for New Zealand's fastest-growing city."

100 tests - no pumice

More than 100 ground tests were done before construction began, says NZTA.

But they failed to spot the pumice layer 12m underground, so groundworks carried on.

Tauranga is on the edge of the Taupō volcanic zone and Bay of Plenty has a lot of pumice underground.

The fact that groundworks failed to properly stabilise the ground only came to light after huge stone columns began going in 10 months ago.

That sparked more tests, including earlier this year at Auckland and Canterbury universities, and the scrapping of the original design.

NZTA says a new design was being finalised.

It was still working out the impacts on the project's cost and timing.

NZTA did not respond to an RNZ question about whether extra costs would fall on the taxpayer.

Even before the pumice problem forced the redesign the project costs had escalated from an early $102m estimate to $146m recently - and its completion had been pushed out from end of this year to end of 2022.

Other complications are the fallout from COVID-19 and an underpass being added to the project.

The B2B project, as it is called, aims to cut congestion on the final run into Tauranga at Baypark where the tolled Eastern Link highway stops - and the traffic slows to a crawl.

The flyovers will take traffic on State Highways 2 and 29 up over roads and the railway line.

Tauranga Mayor Tenby Powell.

The highway is also aimed to boost the local economy and safety for motorists.

Powell says it's vital to complete the region's Eastern Corridor.

"We've got congestion on many of our routes into and out of the city, and we have a tonne of work ahead of us for years to come, so that is very frustrating to learn," he says.

NZTA has not explained how the pumice was not detected at the start.

"This type of testing is not unusual," it says.

"Projects typically do continual tests of ground conditions as they progress through construction and this process can sometimes identify previously unknown ground conditions."

The new design - a combination of stone columns and piles in a lattice framework - was "required to limit settlement and ensure the ground remains stable, ensuring the bridge [at Baypark] is able to withstand seismic events".

The B2B is the latest problem project for the NZTA.

It is grappling with blowouts at the billion-dollar Transmission Gully highway, costly surface cracking on the Kapiti and Waikato highways, and extra engineering reviews and deck-panel testing at the Puhoi to Wellsford highway.

The main contractor at B2B, Australian major CPB, declined to comment. CPB is also key in the Transmission Gully alliance and lead contractor at the strife-hit Acute hospital project in Christchurch.

Powell says NZTA had been good to work with, but had not treated the council as a partner by not telling him about the B2B problems.

"I'm gonna pick up the phone and call the regional director and just try and get an understanding of what exactly has happened, and particularly why we aren't on the same songsheet in terms of communications."

-RNZ/Phil Pennington.

You may also like....

11 comments

Another Expensive mistake!!

Posted on 10-09-2020 09:17 | By Kancho

Unbelievable! is being polite. So I assume dozens of holes were drilled and yet pumice commonly known in the geology wasn't detected ? Huge over spend over time and huge disruption!! Is Tauranga blighted by incompetent geological "experts" reference parking building. Pumice only 12 metres deep just about on the surface ?


Powell

Posted on 10-09-2020 10:06 | By Slim Shady

Maybe NZTA and the road builders should get advice off TCC and the Mayor before embarking on works, seen as TCC are so good at delivering projects successfully.


Cpb

Posted on 10-09-2020 10:19 | By GWHtpt

No surprises here CPB need to be kicked out of our country. Same company that screwed over transmission gully. Everyone in the construction world was warned of them before they turned up. Just ask the contractors that have worked for them !!!!


I can answer that 10B

Posted on 10-09-2020 12:08 | By CC8

The answer to your question is easy! Why would we bother ? You are too busy with your kindergarten level mind games and childish bullying. You have not dealt with anything as serious as a multimillion dollar cost blowout!


Incompetence beyond Comprehension

Posted on 10-09-2020 12:15 | By Equality

Just when you think, surely nothing more can surprise - it does! The required remedial action will continue to cause ongoing traffic mayhem the foreseeable future! Summer time - oh dear! Powell getting a taste of his own medicine here - when not letting ratepayers know what is going on behind TCC's closed doors!


Not TCC or Tenby's fault.

Posted on 10-09-2020 14:29 | By Kancho

Just saying this project is NZTA and started 2017 so trying to blame council or Tenby not accurate. Just saying . Tenby was told on Wednesday so in this instance it's NZTA with the problem of incompetence.


Surely

Posted on 10-09-2020 15:33 | By Now and again

the people who signed all these contracts, on behalf of the NZ Tax payers, with that Australian company had penalty clauses included to cover situations like has happened everywhere this company is involved? If not why not?


Finger Point

Posted on 10-09-2020 16:22 | By Yadick

The blame where the blame is due. As Kancho states, it's not our Council or our Mayor. NZTA have screwed up. Don't ridicule the Mayor for doing his job. You can't finally get what you want and then change direction.


Unbelievable

Posted on 10-09-2020 18:23 | By Told you

Considering we have built hundreds of roads with flyovers you would think they would get it right. Only 36 foot down and it was missed dose not seem possible, poor motorists have to put up with another 2 years of disruption. We need answers.


Yadick and Kancho

Posted on 11-09-2020 08:28 | By Slim Shady

I don’t see any comments blaming Powell or TCC. Maybe you can’t read. What I see is people seeing the hypocrisy of Powell jumping on the blame bandwagon and feeling all let down and disappointed by the stuff up. You have both missed the points entirely.


Negligence

Posted on 11-09-2020 17:35 | By Ceem

Those of us who drove from Baypark to Domain Road while the Expressway was being constructed, didn't need a surveyor to know Pumice was ever present. CPB or their surveyors were negligent, there can be NO excuses. I suppose NZTA allowed a "getout" clause in the contract.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.