NZ taxpayers paid Australian‘s extra MIQ bill

Australian woman Lucinda Baulch spent 28 days in the Grand Mercure after refusing to get a Covid-19 test. Photo: Denise Garland/RNZ

Taxpayers have footed the bill for an Australian woman's extra time in managed isolation, after she refused to get a Covid-19 test.

Australian woman Lucinda Baulch spent 28 days - 14 days longer than usual - in the Grand Mercure in Wellington after refusing to get a test.

The vet nurse flew to New Zealand to deliver three children to their caregivers in February.

She refused a test, arguing she had not been provided with enough evidence of its safety or effectiveness.

However, it was later revealed that she had protested against Covid-19 protection measures in Australia and she had starred in a series of YouTube videos with a notorious conspiracy theorist during her elongated period in managed isolation.

RNZ made a request under the Official Information Act for details of the costs incurred by New Zealand taxpayers in keeping Baulch in MIQ for 28 days.

In its response, a Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment – MBIE - official says there is no requirement to charge more if people stayed longer in MIQ.

"Regarding the additional 14 days, there is no provision to charge any additional amount if someone has to stay for longer than the initial 14 days. If, for example, they have contracted Covid-19, or are a close contact of someone with Covid-19, or have refused to be tested for Covid-19".

Lucinda Baulch. Photo: Stuff.

The MBIE official says they are withholding the details relating to the costs Baulch incurred during her initial 14 days stay due to privacy reasons.

They also are withholding general information about the costs of staying at any particular MIQ facility, as it could "prejudice the ministry's ability to carry out commercial negotiations with MIQ facilities".

The official says it is not possible for MBIE to calculate an accurate "cost to the taxpayer" as other agencies involved, such as NZDF, Ministry of Health, and New Zealand Police, are all responsible for their own funding.

However, a Cabinet Paper from July last year estimates the average cost for a single traveller over 14 days in MIQ would be around $7000.

This does not include costs such as transporting people, or MBIE's overheads to operate the MIQ system.

New Zealand Covid-19 update

On Sunday, the Ministry of Health reported six new cases of Covid-19 in managed isolation from the previous three days. There were no community cases.

Before the long Easter weekend, Covid-19 Response Minister Chris Hipkins urged Kiwis to be vigilant and to remember the importance of using the Covid-tracer app.

The app now has 2.7 million registered users and there were 615,005 poster scans in the 24 hours to 1pm on Sunday.

For Easter, Hamilton's Ibis Tainui Hotel prepared bunny face cloths, egg and spoon races, hot cross buns and the like to brighten up the confinement - and to give staffers a boost as well.

It had to be planned in advance, as hotel staffers can't go into returnees' rooms once they're checked in. Returnees were given a riddle clue one morning so they could begin their Easter egg hunt.

Ibis Tainui Hotel manager Niraj Kumar hoped it would make a difference to those in isolation – as they need the celebrations more than regular guests.

Global toll

It's been a year since our lockdown. A year ago, Covid-19 tipped the lives of New Zealanders upside down and forced five million people indoors amid an unprecedented nationwide lockdown.

Since then, Auckland has been through four lockdowns, a vaccine rollout has begun, and New Zealand has successfully managed to eliminate Covid-19 in the community.

Excluding our closed border, life is relatively back to normal here. However, that's not the case with many countries overseas.

The global number of cases has reached 131.1 million, according to Johns Hopkins University.

Global deaths have surpassed 2.8 million.

The United States continues to record the most cases and fatalities - 30.7 million infections, and 554,985 deaths.
Brazil and India have had the second and third most cases, with 12.9 million and 12.4 million infections, respectively.

What should I do?

Anyone who wants to get tested can find their local testing centres by visiting the Ministry of Health website.

If you are sick, call your GP before you visit, or Healthline on 0800 358 5453.

To avoid contracting and spreading the virus, wash your hands properly, cough and sneeze into the crook of your elbow and throw tissues away immediately.

Reach out, find support from people who care, connect with your community or help a neighbour in need.

10 comments

Soft as...

Posted on 05-04-2021 11:25 | By The Professor

...shit. That's the only description for this country. Why the hell was this moron not charged for the additional time. She refused testing so she should have been made to pay....not ME or the other taxpayers. She should never have been allowed to fly to NZ in the first place given the trouble she caused in Australia. This country and the Government are soft as......toughen up!!! Contrary to what this Government thinks, we do not have an open cheque book.


So what

Posted on 05-04-2021 11:28 | By Slim Shady

This is the least of our worries and is largely irrelevant. I wish journalists in NZ would concentrate on important stories like our woeful vaccination programme and third world healthcare system, rather than click bait crap like this to appeal to morons.


Unbelievable!

Posted on 05-04-2021 11:50 | By Equality

What a cheek! But then what a stupid government for not putting it on the next plane back where it came from?


Hahaha

Posted on 05-04-2021 12:38 | By Let's get real

Nothing that happens at the moment surprises me at all. We are still allowing people into the country without having a test before boarding the flight here and although, at present, we don't have any community cases, we are still getting daily announcements of positive cases being detected in MIQ.... Are we also footing the bill for the extended stays of those testing positive in MIQ on day twelve...? And in her case, why wasn't she deported immediately after refusing her test the first time. Test or leave.


More Empathy

Posted on 05-04-2021 13:19 | By Bob Landy

Sounds like someone in government had her nurse’s empathy hat on


Should have been DEPORTED

Posted on 05-04-2021 14:24 | By The Caveman

on the day she refused her FIRST test.


no I dont know you

Posted on 05-04-2021 17:05 | By hapukafin

What mickey mouse law makers we have in our government..Dont prosecute covid law breakers when they feel like it.Lucky that not all our law breakers have someone to back them up in higher places.


@Slim Shady

Posted on 06-04-2021 10:49 | By morepork

"...click bait crap like this to appeal to morons." And yet you clicked on it and even responded to it... :-) I agree with you that journalists should cover more responsible issues but they aren't mutually exclusive. We need to know about nonsense like this too.


No brainer.

Posted on 06-04-2021 10:50 | By morepork

Mark her card as "PNG" (Persona Non Grata) and deport her back to Oz immediately. She should be unwelcome here and unable to come here.


Cheek!

Posted on 13-04-2021 09:38 | By CliftonGuy

Return to sender. Why do we want annoying Australians? If she doesn't want to tow the line, then she should go back. AND PAY THE COSTS AS WELL!


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.