Land wars institute in Gate Pā one step closer

: An artist’s impression of the Gate Pā/Pukehinahina cultural centre. Image: Supplied.

A pathway forward has been made for a 'desperately needed” cultural centre in Tauranga that will tell the story of the New Zealand land wars.

At a Tauranga City Council meeting today the commissioners voted to reclassify part of the Gate Pā Recreation Reserve to historic reserve to enable the proposed national institute of the New Zealand land wars to be built.

In 2020, the council received a proposal from the Pukehinahina Charitable Trust, in partnership with mana whenua Ngāi Tamarāwaho, to establish a cultural and historic centre on the Gate Pā Recreation Reserve.

The proposed centre would tell the history of all the New Zealand land wars with a 'natural focus” on the Battle of Gate Pā and Te Ranga because of its location, said Ngāi Tamarāwaho representative and trust member Buddy Mikaere.

It was expected to provide a workshop space, exhibition areas, performing arts space, plus room for a visitor experience of contemporary and traditional Māori life.

The Battle of Pukehinahina (Gate Pā) took place on the reserve site on April 29 1864. It was fought on a ridge known as Pukehinahina.

The pā consisted of two redoubts with trenches and bunkers to trap the British.

Māori were successful in their defence, with 35 British troops killed and 75 wounded, twice the estimated Māori casualties.

An overview of the land at Gate Pā Reserve and the proposed site for the centre. Image: Supplied.

During the meeting's public forum Ngāi Tamarāwaho representative Kalani Tarawa said Tauranga 'desperately needed” a cultural centre.

Speaking about the history, Tarawa said 'most” of his Ngāi Tamarāwaho hapu had to leave Tauranga after the wars because they 'didn't have land to sustain” them.

'There's nothing we can do to change injustices of the past.

'I'm glad we've come to the maturity and understand it [the history], and look to provide a way forward that accepts and respects both cultures,” said Tarawa.

'I can't overstate the importance of having a cultural centre and something that unites us, where both sides are respected and the true history is remembered.”

He said there was 'no shame” in what had happened and 'the only thing we can affect is today and the future”.

The cultural centre was an 'opportunity ... to establish a bright future for our kids for our grandchildren,” said Tarawa.

He also paid tribute to his ancestors who had fought in the battle. Tarawa's great, great grand-uncle was the first person killed and a great grandfather, who was 'only a teenager” was in one of the small redoubts.

Speaking to the proposal, commissioner Shadrach Rolleston also acknowledged his ancestors and others that fought in the battle.

Two of his ancestors survived and raised families and one 'wasn't so lucky”, he said.

Commissioner Shadrach Rolleston. Photo: John Borren/SunLive.

Rolleston said the location 'makes sense” given the 'significance of Pukehinahina” to Ngāi Tamarāwaho, Tauranga Moana, all its iwi and hapu and the 'tribes that heeded the call to come and support the tribes here against the threat of invasion”.

'The site is not just of local significance and not just regional significance, but actually of national significance.

'Regardless of the way we feel about our history, the good and the bad, and the ugly. It's our history and we need to acknowledge it.”

The cultural centre was also 'honouring” an 'outstanding” agreement between council and Ngāi Tamarāwaho, said Rolleston.

In 1999 the council entered into a memorandum of understanding with the hapu to investigate options for a cultural and historic centre.

Commissioner Bill Wasley said history in Tauranga 'is either not told or it's not evident as you live here, [and] you move around [here].”

'The reclassification and then ultimately the development of a cultural and history centre, will hopefully fill some of that gap for all of the residents in the city, but also those that come here and visit.”

The council ran public consultation on the reclassification of around 6716m2 of the reserve from September 12 to October 12.

Of the 63 submissions received, 56 were in support of the proposed reclassification, six strongly opposed it and one was neutral.

Concerns raised by those opposed included who would pay for the centre and the ongoing operational costs, and if this would fall on ratepayers.

Addressing those concerns, Rolleston said council didn't have a proposal in front of them and a process needed to be followed.

'If there is a request for additional funding … Crown funding would be the ideal scenario, given its [the centre's] national significance.”

Rolleston said council would need to consult with the community if a funding request was made.

Ngāi Tamarāwaho representative and historian Buddy Mikaere. File photo: SunLive.

Speaking after the meeting Mikaere said the 'target” for funding was 'not the rate payers but central government” and other 'philanthropic interests”.

'The sheer weight of the supporting submissions, shows you that this is something that our community overall wants.”

Mikaere reiterated the centre was of 'national importance”, especially as New Zealand history was becoming 'a central part of the new school curriculum”.

'History is history and the best thing we can do is make sure it's told properly.”

Now the reclassification has been confirmed, council staff will work with Ngāi Tamarāwaho and the Pukehinahina Charitable Trust on a lease arrangement that will go out for public consultation.

Public Interest Journalism funded through NZ On Air.

11 comments

Hmmm..

Posted on 28-11-2022 17:29 | By jed

Wouldn't a statue or memorial do the trick? If we construct a building for every minor skirmish then we'd go broke! Since British suffered the twice as many casualties I expect somewhat more focus on the British story. Perhaps they could turn this into an overall war museum? Covering all wars.


Rubbish

Posted on 28-11-2022 18:43 | By Let's get real

A cultural centre is NOT desperately needed. We already have centres around the country that have been setup to tell the history of NZ and having visited most I'm bitterly disappointed with the way history is twisted to suit the current environment. We are too quick to forget that Governmental and Royal expectations have changed in the intervening years and soldiers are no longer likely to be shot by a firing squad for failing to follow orders. I don't imagine anyone who has served their country in the military forces would want to be in the position faced by the British forces in that era. Firing squad, maybe get served up as a meal and no way to leave the country.


Cameron road

Posted on 28-11-2022 18:45 | By Kancho

This will probably cause more traffic woes building and then attending traffic. So we pay for a defacto museum when one is already being built regardless. We also will be paying for the Joyce road battle site development . Seems the Joyce road site would be far better better with more space. Not to mention that ratepayers don't need to pay three times for the town museum, the Gate Pa proposal and the Joyce road site.


Important

Posted on 28-11-2022 20:20 | By Informed

Such an important story to tell. The lies and underhanded action that lead to the slaughter of a massive number of the local Iwi needs to be told. Such a shame to see the typical Sunlive reader continuing to act like it’s 1960.


Enough Room

Posted on 28-11-2022 21:18 | By Yadick

To make this the ONLY museum. Forget about another one in the CBD. We've already got the Historic Village which can easily be turned into the Museum instead of just quirky little shops and dingy little offices - it's wasted. It could be SO much more. Why do we need museums dotted all around our bankrupt city. Build one museum and make it count if you must spend the money we haven't got on things we don't want (at present) or forget the entire idea.


How about

Posted on 28-11-2022 21:27 | By The Caveman

We forget about the PAST and stop spending MILLIONS on it, and actually look FORWARD to the future ! And spend the SAME $$$ on the future !!!


Couldn’t agree more.

Posted on 29-11-2022 07:23 | By Shadow1

The Musket Wars happened in much the same period as the Land Wars and were particularly awful for Maori. Also Moriori should have a mention. Shadow1.


Read between the lines

Posted on 29-11-2022 08:20 | By an_alias

So no mention of who is paying for this ? Just watch the bill be given to the ratepayer, there is no end to the spending by the 4. Laughing all the way to the....


Commenters are rednecks.

Posted on 29-11-2022 20:09 | By Old Bloke

In the late 90s. The Garage/Petrol station was up for sale. I had the idea to build a "tourist" site there to cover the Battle of Gate Pah. It is a great story on both sides of the conflict. My approach to local Maori was positive. Unfortunately the land behind the Garage was heavily contaminated by used engine oil which made the economics untenable, in that many hundreds of thousands could have been spent removing contaminated soil. Now of course the bloody poor ratepayer and taxpayer will be funding it instead of Private enterprise ie me and some investors.


@Old Bloke

Posted on 30-11-2022 13:55 | By morepork

Thanks for your very interesting comment and revelation regarding the contaminated soil. I believe your assessment of what will happen in this regard is probably correct.


Who pays three separate sights

Posted on 30-11-2022 21:47 | By Kancho

Town museum, Joyce road , and Gate Pa. "The trouble with Socialism is that eventually you run out of other people's money."


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.