Trucking industry rejects pothole claim

A pothole on SH27 which has been recently patched over. Supplied photo/SunLive.

Trucking advocates are rejecting the government's claim that massive vehicles introduced onto New Zealand roads just over a decade ago are to partly to blame for the subsequent rise in reports of potholes.

In the first 10 months of 2022 there were 555 complaints of vehicle damage caused by potholes reported to Waka Kotahi, up from 421 in all of 2021 - a rise of about 58 per cent.

In 2020, there were just 298 complaints.

Tauranga motorcyclist Paul Webb says his bike was "written-off" after he hit a pothole on SH27. Read his story in full here.

"It shows what Kiwis have been feeling on the roads for some time, but I think there would be a whole lot more people over summer who have had this experience with potholes," Ia Ara Aotearoa chief executive Nick Leggett told Morning Report.

"Obviously it's costly, it delays trips and it's also a safety concern as well. That's concerning because we've got 'road to zero' in the background, and it just is another area where the government is not meeting those targets."

Before the summer break, National Party transport spokesperson Simeon Brown regularly tweeted pictures of and news stories about potholes, prompting a lengthy series of tweets in response from Transport Minister Michael Wood.

Wood dug up a number of alleged causes, including a freeze in roading maintenance under the previous National-led government, an 'extremely wet winter", and National's decision in 2010 to allow 50MAX trucks - which can weigh up to 50 tonnes - on certain roads.

Wood said these "heavier trucks do a lot more damage" owing to something called the "fourth power law".

Basically, the more weight each axle of a vehicle is required to bear, the damage done to the road increases exponentially, to the power of four - so an axle bearing 10 tonnes, for example, would put 10,000 times as much stress on the road as one carrying a single tonne.

Brown tweeted that Wood was "digging his own pothole", saying Labour had years to fix the problem but "all the minister has got is to blame the previous [government]".

Leggett says Waka Kotahi's website cites peer-reviewed studies on 50MAX trucks which prove, due to "the way their axles are configured … they distribute the weight evenly".

"They're no heavier on the road than any truck that was previously on the road. It's an easy and a cheap shot, but it's not one that's backed up with evidence."

Bigger trucks also means fewer trips, he says, resulting in fewer carbon emissions.

A spokesperson for the minister told RNZ the government has boosted its road maintenance budget by 50 per cent to "help bring our roads back up to scratch", and over the next few years will invest $7 billion into renewing "around 7000 lane kilometres of state highway and 18,000 lane kilometres of local roads".

"High volumes of rainfall affected both state highways and local roads last year, making it a very challenging environment, particularly regarding potholes.

"In August the Minister of Transport sought assurances from Waka Kotahi that there was a clear plan to communicate to the public around why potholes were appearing on parts of the network, and the repair plan.

"Waka Kotahi contractors nationally have been working around the clock to address the impact of the recent severe weather events on the state highway network."

In the 2021/22 financial year, the spokesperson said more than 45,000 potholes were repaired on state highways alone - and Waka Kotahi was in the middle of "undertaking the largest ever programme of spring and summer state highway renewals".

Leggett says that highlighted another problem.

"To be fair to the government, they have injected more money … right at the time when we've got a labour shortage, and that means that sometimes it's harder for contractors to get work done," says Leggett.

"But there's so much work to do, it's overwhelming."

-RNZ.

7 comments

Just excuses........

Posted on 17-01-2023 07:42 | By groutby

....for the poor condition of the roads, the additional and seemingly never ending taxes/tolls and any amount of $$$ that can be squeezed from road users does not seems to have transformed into higher quality surfaces to drive on. If only we could have access to where these funds are actually going we will probably always wonder, 'other' transport projects and consultants maybe? Perhaps interestingly there appears to be a similar situation in UK with poor quality road surfaces also..... conspiracy theorists would doubtless have a field day, and maybe not without reason........


A freeze on maintenance

Posted on 17-01-2023 08:21 | By Johnney

This was five years ago by National. One has to ask what has Labour been doing the last 5 years. Not a lot by the looks of it.


Road 2 Zero

Posted on 17-01-2023 08:33 | By The Professor

How about NZTA and the Government have anothother campaign.......this one could be called Road 2 Zero 2....and this could aim to have Zero potholes!! NZTA and the Government should focus on things which do make a difference, such as fixing Road surfaces, instead of plugging billions into a ridiculous campaign to reduce deaths to zero.


Always, Everytime

Posted on 17-01-2023 08:40 | By Yadick

There's someone else or something else to blame. Just get on and do the job. Despite so-called massive advances in road surfacing technology our roads are the worst I can remember them being. Forget about tar slinging in Parliament and being right bitumens with muck raking about it, JUST GET THE JOB DONE. As a I frequent Tga Hospital I find Clarke Street increasingly dangerous. Big pothole corner 17th and Clarke, series of potholes leading up to crossing on Clarke Street, then a big pothole in the pedestrian crossing itself and while trying to dodge those you need to look out for pedestrians stepping out from behind the plantings at the pedestrian crossing. As groutby states, just excuses.


Roading

Posted on 17-01-2023 08:48 | By Pensioner

We have lived on a country road that is tarsealed. The repairs that are done can not stand the test of time if a wet day can make potholes. To me it is more a case of using inferior products or using workers that don't know what they are doing. Try using some concrete in the mix, or use experienced workers.


Oil refinery

Posted on 17-01-2023 09:56 | By Kancho

Bitumen was a by product of the Marsden point refinery but now has to be imported. Some say an inferior product is also not helping. So greeny inspired refinery closure has created downstream issues when we recently had imported jet fuel quality shortages and now serious shortages of carbon dioxide/ dry ice supplies hampering our exports . From. Government who never sees or admits a y crisis, yet every week another one while the slumber behind the wheel. Roll on the elections to be rid of their ideologies that have dragged us down divided us and attacked democratic processes


Pot holes

Posted on 18-01-2023 22:17 | By maunganui

There are thousands of kms of roads though out NZ forestry to handle large truck loads of 50 to 80 tonneau plus, no pot holes in forestry roads, it's time the government lifted the standard of construction.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.