Tauranga man‘s growing frustration at toll roads

Pāpāmoa resident Ian Young is growing frustrated with Tauranga’s toll roads. Photo: File/SunLive.

A Pāpāmoa resident is taking his opinions on toll roads to Parliament.

Ian Young is retired, and spends his time volunteering at Classic Flyers in Tauranga.

But he is growing frustrated with the ongoing cost of toll roads in the city he calls home, and says it is 'unfair” Tauranga houses two of the three roads which cost to drive on in New Zealand.

His view comes as a Waka Kotahi spokesperson tells SunLive Tauranga's two toll roads have earned more than $90 million from motorists.

Ian says one particular toll road, Takitimu Drive, is a 'B-grade road” while there are 'superior expressways and motorways” which are toll free.

He has put his opinion forth to Parliament, which currently has 25 days left to gather signatures before being addressed to the House of Representatives.

The 78-year-old retiree says it is important people's opinions are heard. Photo: Supplied/SunLive.

"Plenty of people in this city feel the same. Plenty of people in Tauranga believe it is unfair we have two of the three toll roads,” says Ian.

Ian's number one reason for starting the petition is to figure out 'why Tauranga is being targeted” in regards to toll roads.

He first reached out to an MP who suggested he start a petition to bring to Parliament.

Ian says he understands why toll roads are put in place, but suggests it is 'unfair” to have toll roads in place when they are inferior quality to other new highway projects.

'If there is a toll on a road, there should be a minimum quality standard it has to meet. Any road which meets the standard should carry a toll. The money from this should be used to maintain the roads and go towards future projects, however the toll roads we do have would not meet the quality standard.

'What are we paying our taxes on our petrol purchases for? It's a double hit. We pay a tax on our petrol purchases, a lot more than other countries, which is supposed to go towards roads and highways.

'When you look at the Takitimu Drive, it makes you wonder why you are paying for it in the first place. I see road workers there, but it seems like the things they're working on is gardens and cycle lanes rather than the surface work.”

Ian says he doesn't expect a 'positive outcome” from the Parliamentary petition, but he thinks it is 'important peoples opinions are heard”.

While consulting the Tauranga public in 2009, Waka Kotahi says there was considerable support for toll roads. Photo: File/SunLive.

According to a Waka Kotahi spokesperson, there was 'considerable public support” for toll roads in Tauranga.

'For example, in 2009, public were consulted on whether they supported the Tauranga Eastern Link being a toll road so construction to start up to 10 years earlier," says the Waka Kotahi spokesperson.

'Tolling received significant community support, with 92 per cent voting conditional and unconditional.

'There are free alternative routes available for those who do not want to pay a toll for using these roads.”

Waka Kotahi says there is no debt in relation to Takitimu Drive, as the organisation paid $65 million to purchase the road from Tauranga City Council, which they are currently 'recovering with national interest from toll revenues”.

From financial years 2015/16 to 2020/21, Tauranga's toll roads have earned approximately $90,536,000.

For Tauranga's Eastern Link, the road has earned $44,200,000 in this period. Approximately $29,593,000 is being used to repay debt, principal and interest for the road, while $14,607,000 is being used by Waka Kotahi to operate toll business.

Image: SunLive.

Takitimu Drive earned a total of $46,336,000 between financial years 2015/16 to 2020/21.

Around $30,516,000 is being used to repay the debt, principal and interest, while $15,820,000 is being used to operate the toll business.

Waka Kotahi first purchased Takitimu Drive from Tauranga City Council for $65 million. By currently modelling, this is expected to be paid off by 2031.

Tauranga Eastern Link is expected to be paid off by 2040 by current modelling.

The organisation is also considering further toll roads, including Ōtaki to North of Levin and the Takitimu North project.

'If the Government approves tolling Penlink, the tolling scheme would be in place when the road is open in 2026.”

18 comments

Alternatives not viable

Posted on 19-01-2023 07:22 | By TGA Local07

Problem with Takitimu Dr toll road is the fact the alternative routes are untenable if you want to get home at a reasonable time. I tell ya what, Cameron Road had better turn out to be the next best thing in a few years time for all of the headaches that roadworks has caused.


Come on elected members

Posted on 19-01-2023 07:42 | By Womby

Surely it should not take a 78 year old pensioner to do your job and rectify a glaring anomaly New road opened in Wellington, no toll New highway from Cambridge north, no toll Rough as roads in Tauranga, loose chip on one and toll road! And sounds like another toll soon on the shortened North link Come on our elected members for this area Show your face and do your job


Toll tunnel

Posted on 19-01-2023 09:03 | By CliftonGuy

I do not use the toll roads, mainly because the process of paying is too convoluted. However, I would be glad to pay a toll on a tunnel through the Kaimais. But, I suppose pigs might fly.


Under

Posted on 19-01-2023 09:24 | By Merlin

Under a previous Minister of Transport and our local MP at the time.


Its about taxing and control

Posted on 19-01-2023 09:24 | By an_alias

Get ready for the next idea which will be 15 minute cities and taxing you for driving period. Just look at the floating tax on petrol which is then taxed again with GST. The higher the price the more money govt takes.


Toll roads - okay.

Posted on 19-01-2023 12:01 | By The Professor

Happy to have the odd toll road because it keeps those routes free of congestion. If the tolls were removed from TD and EL, those roads would become like the others around our region.....gridlocked. Happy for new NL to be a toll road too.


It seems to me that...

Posted on 19-01-2023 13:05 | By morepork

... if you have to pay to use a road (given that maintenance is supposed to be covered by petrol tax etc.), then that road should be of high quality and it should offer some advantage. Maybe a higher speed limit, or wider lanes, or SOMETHING that warrants an extra charge. The discontent is because we are not seeing any such thing.


@TheProfessor

Posted on 19-01-2023 13:30 | By an_alias

No need for tolls, you can just donate your money directly to the govt.


14 - 16 million to operate toll business??

Posted on 19-01-2023 14:24 | By fair game

Explain that again?? Majority of tolls are paid online, why is it so expensive to run a fee service?


Daizy

Posted on 19-01-2023 15:07 | By Davy

Winston Promised if he got into power 2017 he would have Takitimu Drive Tolls removed HAHA


I can't help but wonder....

Posted on 19-01-2023 15:07 | By groutby

.....how the revenue 'retained' by NZTA to 'operate toll business' is so vast....around $30 million conbined for the stated financial years, and yet the tolling infrastructure is surely largely automated isnt it?...seems very steep?


I remember

Posted on 19-01-2023 17:21 | By SonnyJim

I seem to remember we did a bit of queue-jumping by getting the Te Puke bypass built, and a weaponised Winston got us the harbour bridges, so what's to moan about?


@an alias

Posted on 19-01-2023 20:45 | By The Professor

You've missed the point - a donation directly to the Government won't keep roads quiet.


Toll idiotic debacle

Posted on 19-01-2023 20:49 | By Sturba

We all get taxed and taxed and domes times triple taxed for everything (money we earn and money that goes out) and there increasing the tolls and number of toll roads. For goodness sake don't do that. Use the tax to fix up the road and make new project.


Level playing field please

Posted on 19-01-2023 22:42 | By Otumoetai Resident

Nice work Ian Young you said what many of us have been thinking. Why pay twice for roads when the rest of the country pays none bar the tunnel north of Orewa. What about the toll free Waterwiew tunnel , the Waikato Expressway, Transmission Gully etc... Tauranga residents are being stitched up due to sub standard MP representation. Winston Peters (love him or hate him) got the tolls off the bridge (another historic example) A level playing field for all kiwis. Politicians see our city as a soft touch, look we dont even have the right to vote any more. Just wait till Labour loses the next election maybe we might get a more level playing field and democracy returns to our city


Toll roads in Tauranga

Posted on 20-01-2023 11:00 | By Leprechaun

Several comments. I believe in toll roads but the cost could reduced. Why are motorcyclists charged the same amount bc as a car? Trucks are custom ore than a car, understandably. SO WHY are motorcycles not charged less than a car? I would like to know where the excess, after paying off the loan goes. For example in KATIKATI we have been waiting a bypass, why not help towards that? The infrastructure is in place even. Just get on with it, even if it has to be tolled.


Happy

Posted on 20-01-2023 15:54 | By Kancho

First it's easy to pay the toll as one can have an account that covers all toll roads and automatic tops up so quite efficient and no hassle. Second I agree with the professor tolls keep the road relatively clear and so I'm happy to pay a toll without hassles. If free it would be serious gridlock especially at the Tauriko roundabout. It's still years to get the northern link and Cambridge road sorted I love the toll roads north of Auckland too .


I support tolls

Posted on 21-01-2023 12:41 | By jed

Tolls are a great way to get roads we need. But, why is Tauranga targeted? Hamilton has no tolls, nor Wellington Dunedin or Christchurch. Auckland does have a 10c petrol tax though.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.