New Tauranga courthouse hold ups spark debate

Tauranga MP Sam Uffindell, left, and Acting Justice Minister Andrew Little share their views on the Tauranga Courthouse development. Photo: Samuel Rillstone/RNZ.

Tauranga MP Sam Uffindell is calling on the Government to 'get moving” with the city's new courthouse development.

Initially set for completion in 2026, the project was put 'under review” after inflationary cost pressures post Covid-19.

The $150 million courthouse, so far, has cost taxpayers about $27 million, but a business case has yet to be made.

Uffindell suggests Justice Minister Kiri Allan expects the business case for the project to be made before the end of the financial year – March 31, 2024.

'Tauranga is paying the price for this government's failure to control inflation.”

'At present, the city's justice precinct faces significant constraints and is unable to deal with the huge volume of cases.

'Since 2018, Tauranga District Court jury trials have doubled and Tauranga High Court jury trials have quadrupled.

'In 2021, then-Minister Faafoi announced over $150 million had been approved to build new courts here in Tauranga. If built, it will increase the number of courtrooms, allowing cases to be heard here in Tauranga instead of being shifted to Rotorua.

Uffindell also says completion of the new courthouse by 2026 is 'looking about as likely as Auckland Light Rail by 2021”.

'There are very real fears this Government will significantly delay or downsize construction.”

The Ministry of Justice expects a business case for the new courthouse to be presented to Cabinet later this year. Photo: File/SunLive.

Ministry of Justice deputy secretary, corporate and digital services Tina Wakefield says they expect a detailed business case to be presented to Cabinet 'around the middle of this year”.

On whether the project will be completed by 2026, Tina says the estimated completion date 'will depend” on the outcome of the business case and the option chosen by Cabinet.

She says she is 'aware” Tauranga's current courthouse is 'too small” to meet future demand, particularly with the High Court.

'This is one of the reasons the project to build a new courthouse in Tauranga was started,” says Tina.

'The buildings will also address the safety needs of all court participants, including victims, be more family-friendly, and meet physical accessibility requirements for all building users.”

SunLive also put the question to the Ministry of Justice on whether the construction will be downsized.

'Like all construction projects, costs associated with the new courthouse have significantly increased due to inflation and supply constraints.

'Within this significantly increasing cost environment, the Ministry is reviewing the approach to the new courthouse.”

Acting Justice Minister Andrew Little. Photo: Samuel Rillstone/RNZ.

Acting Justice Minister Andrew Little also acknowledges the limitations of Tauranga's current courthouse.

'It's clear the current courthouse is too small to accommodate future demand, and has a number of other challenges that mean it cannot be used to its full potential. These are all reasons why the project to build a new courthouse in Tauranga was started,” says Little.

'A detailed business case will be presented to Cabinet later this year, and the future shape of this project will depend on the outcome of that business case and the option chosen by Cabinet.

'We remain committed to a courthouse in Tauranga that is fit for purpose for Tauranga and meets contemporary expectations.”

6 comments

Its just another building and not a monument.

Posted on 13-04-2023 07:21 | By Cynical Me

There is a a large empty building in cameron rd just along from the courthouse that could be put to use. It's called the Bonguard Centre. Plenty of cases that require no special security that could be held there. The uni doesn't use it any more now that have their swanky leaky new building.


How about build it in a suitable area

Posted on 13-04-2023 07:39 | By Womby

It may well have been built originally in a suitable location but it needs to be in an area with transport almost to the door, a huge parking area, easy access,ie not Cameron Road, and built for the next hundred years as this city’s population grows. Think Baypark style setup Most of the people attending the courthouse for many reasons either have no car, no excess money for parking and council tickets! Except perhaps lawyers


Build it somewhere else

Posted on 13-04-2023 10:06 | By an_alias

All we can say is Little by name and Little by nature he does produce. Why so much money, useless govt sector is all I can say.


Good point from Womby.

Posted on 13-04-2023 12:46 | By morepork

Why don't they put it on the Racecourse? :-) Seriously, it needs to be somewhere that the new buses can run to and it should have plenty of parking. Traditionally, courthouses are part of the mid-city CBD (like the Library and City Hall) but we need to depart from tradition here. I'd be looking at Pye's Pa or Oropi roads...


Not

Posted on 13-04-2023 12:48 | By Merlin

Not another saga like the Dunedin hospital under the previous governments terms which still has not been built I hope.


Interesting...

Posted on 13-04-2023 12:57 | By morepork

They approved $150 million during the Covid epidemic, (when money seemed to have no meaning...) then, as the threat declines and they took stock of the financial carnage, they start to get cold feet and back off. I'd really like to know how there could ever have been any action on this without a Business Case. You don't start something THEN fabricate a Business Case... It's like a horse pushing a cart. You make a Business Case, get approval for your $150 million, then design, review, approve, and build. If the costs go up, you modify the plan and stay within the allocated funds; the plan should be modular and able to be changed if required. 7% cost increase, means 7% less facility. You don't just stop and debate the funding; you already had that debate...


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.