Tauranga dubbed "abandoned city"

A travel vlogger was "distressed" at how many empty shops and businesses were in Tauranga, as well as the amount of construction. Photo: Supplied.

A travel vlogger has dubbed Tauranga, “New Zealand’s abandoned city” – “a ghost town”, with empty businesses and non-stop construction, which its MP attributed to the “wrecking ball” approach of the city’s non-elected commissioners.

YouTuber and TikToker, Curls, a Brit who vlogs about places he visits, says the amount of empty buildings in Tauranga was distressing, and it made him feel sad.

With its summer vibe, palm trees, dazzling waterfronts and beaches, Tauranga could be an Australasian Miami, says Curls, but he's puzzled at all the road cones and ghost town feel.

It’s not the first time visitors to Tauranga have been stunned by its empty CBD and endless roadworks.

Ongoing roadworks have caused jams worse than Auckland, and have won Tauranga the dubious crown of having the worst traffic in Aotearoa.

Visitors to Tauranga have commented on the number of empty shops and businesses. Photo: Annemarie Quill, Stuff.

Connie Richards, co-owner of Elizabeth Cafe and Larder, says road cones and fluorescent orange now give her trauma.

Her café is on Tauranga’s main drag, Cameron Road, where construction has been going on all year.

“It has put customers off visiting because roadworks are right outside businesses doors,” says Connie

“At one stage, if you wanted to come in, you’d have to drive ages up the main road, turn back round a roundabout and even then you can’t park – it’s too hard, especially for our elderly regulars, and people use all their gas driving around detours.”

Connie Richards and George Gibson co owners of Elizabeth Cafe and Larder say the Cameron Rd construction has affected their business leaving her traumatised at the sight of a road cone and fluorescent orange. Photo: Stuff.

The construction impacted business so badly that Connie had to work other jobs to pay rent, and drop staff.

“It’s our worst year ever. At weekends, we are down 78 per cent, and overall 35 per cent. I’ve never been so sick – it’s stress, being in a constant dog fight with council, who just don’t care how this is affecting us all.”

Further up Cameron Road is Tauranga’s first-ever Indian restaurant, Talk of India, which opened in 1993. Regular diner Josie Buchan urged locals to help.

“I'm so heartbroken to hear that due to the ongoing Cameron Road roadworks, they are struggling to stay afloat. His words were, even worse than Covid times.”

More locals vowed to visit to support the much-loved family restaurant that they had eaten at over the years, berating council for killing off local business. One man even recalled his wife’s waters breaking in there and that baby is now 24.

Ash Gee, owner of popular cocktail bar and restaurant, Miss Gee's and chair of Downtown Tauranga presented a petition to council over the closure of a central city car park that businesses say will impact trade. Photo:Stuff.

This week, Ash Gee, owner of Miss Gee’s bar in central Tauranga, and chair of the local business association presented a petition with now more than 3000 signatures to council asking it to delay a $84m waterfront construction project that would mean a central car park would have to close.

“There’s overwhelming concern from the business community on the timing of the project. Running a business in a city that’s being torn apart and rebuilt is extremely tough,” says Ash.

Ash also encouraged locals to support affected businesses.

Tauranga MP Sam Uffindell says the petition demonstrated “huge concern” about losing the car park.

“Many believe it will kill a number of already struggling businesses.”

Tauranga City Council commission chair Anne Tolley. Photo: Mark Taylor, Stuff.

Sam laid the blame with the four non-elected Commissioners chaired by former National MP, Anne Tolley, who has been running the city since 2021, when they were appointed to replace a dysfunctional administration lead by former mayor, Tenby Powell.

“Businesses in Tauranga feel that the Commissioners don’t care if they go under. I find the Commissioners’ wilful ignorance of the concerns of Tauranga CBD businesses extremely concerning,” says Sam.

“Tauranga City Council is acting like a wrecking ball to many small businesses in the city and along Cameron Road.

They claim to be working to restore the heartbeat of the city, but many of the businesses are on life support, and TCC is making it worse with their avalanche of impediments.

“The Cameron Road disaster, paid parking, closure of the Strand car park and reduction in nightlife hours just continue to hammer businesses.”

“This reinforces the need to restore local democracy in Tauranga as soon as possible so local people and local businesses can hold local body politicians accountable,” says Sam.

Commission Chair, Anne Tolley, says the waterfront car park closure had to happen to revitalise the waterfront with new greenspace that will bring more people into the centre.

 “The transformation of our city centre is a once-in-a-generation opportunity, but it will mean that people may not be able to park in the same places they’re used to.”

Tauranga needs to go through this period to make it a great city, says Anne.

“With the upgrade of the waterfront reserve, Council’s $306 million investment in Te Manawataki o Te Papa, a new civic precinct, and an estimated $1.5 billion of planned private sector investment in the city centre, prosperity will return to what has been a neglected asset.”

Tauranga MP Sam Uffindell is concerned about the “wilful ignorance” of the city’s commissioners about how worried local businesses are, and says the city needs to return to democracy, so local body politicians can be held to account. Photo: Supplied.

The civic precinct will not be completed until the end of 2028.

While current construction on Cameron Rd is estimated to be finished by Christmas, locals may be surprised to learn that that was only Stage 1, with Stage 2 scheduled for 2025.

Anne acknowledged the level of disruption the stage 1 works have caused for many businesses.

“More should have been done sooner to ease the problems being experienced. Projects on this scale will inevitably cause some disruption, but the council understands its responsibility to keep that disruption to an absolute minimum.”

“It’s clear that we need to do better in future and the business community and road users can expect to see that duty of care exercised and work-related disruptions minimised wherever possible,” says Council chief executive Marty Grenfell.

As for Elizabeth Cafe’s Connie Richards, her “dog fight” with council has resulted in a promise that the construction outside will end this month.

“But they said that last month, so we’ll see.”

- Stuff

12 comments

TCC

Posted on 14-11-2023 10:33 | By davidt5

If the commissioners were genuinely trying to help Tauranga to revitalise then the work would be completed as quickly as possible. This should mean that work on the upgrades are going on at the rate of 24 hours each day until the improvements have been completed. There is absolutely no excuse for the works to have dragged on over the past few years with even more years of pain to come. GET ON AND GET THE WORK DONE QUICKLY.


Saving Money

Posted on 14-11-2023 11:40 | By Yadick

Visit Tauranga and save. An abomination to travel around - so not wanting to saves you fuel.
Window shopping 24/7.
Tauranga - the city you have when you don't have a city.
SHAME ON YOU COMMISSIONERS.
But hoping you enjoy the morning teas and lunches that your servants deliver to you so you don't need to venture out into YOUR absolute mess.
Surely we can stand together and have these Commissioners removed and democracy restored.
Come on Sam Uffindell - help your city.


Finally published

Posted on 14-11-2023 11:42 | By an_alias

Yeah its a real shame this has only been reported in comments that are ritually blocked.
Its seems paid adverts are preferred for the dysfunctional un-elected


Old Boys Club

Posted on 14-11-2023 12:16 | By Artemis

The TCC councillors were fired as they were not acting in the best interests of their constituency. The Commissioners are kickstarting critical infrastructure remedial work and have a vision for reinvigorating the heart of the city. Its not fair to point the finger at them, its the old boys club that were the previous councillors that should be held to account. Why are people so short-sighted?? Even Tenby Powell couldn't rein them in he called for the council to be replaced by Commissioners as they were dysfunctional and this was why they were brought in. Good riddance and well done on the Commissioners for getting things moving.


Commissioners a disaster

Posted on 14-11-2023 12:46 | By jed

Just wait until ratepayers have to start paying the new 'commissioners' levy to pay for their 300 million dollar white elephant CBD project.

They said the average levy was $300? Which means half of ratepayers could be paying a lot more.

Links ave is an abomination, councils road manager Brendan Bisley has destroyed Tauranga roading single handedly. Cameron road changes are also an abomination, they're trying to slow traffic and make people ride their bikes. Talk about progress!

Councils seem to attract those with left wing views, such as we see in Wellington. Look at what is happening in the Wellington council (which is destroying finances), but Tauranga council seems to have a similar philosophy.


Don't forget

Posted on 14-11-2023 15:24 | By Old Grumpy

Yes I agree with the criticism of the Commissioners but what about the Company appointed to actually do the work? Whenever I travel along Cameron Road there appears to be only a minimum number of workers actually working and even then only some of the time. There are large stretches where nothing is being touched. Seems to me that the Company may have bitten off much more than they can chew. Perhaps any future contracts should have penalty clauses to help avoid these stuff ups?


Agree, Artemis!

Posted on 14-11-2023 16:35 | By WestieMum

Totally agree with you Artemis - it was an old boys club who coveted their seats in Council, looking after their own patch with their own agendas, trying to be popular with the populace. Never mind the city they were ruining in the process. The old Tauranga has gone and it's population size means we have to move forward. Unfortunately the inward mindset of previous Councils means we have a lot of catching up to do. Running a city like ours is a multi million dollar business, and we put people in charge by voting on their catching slogans and billboards. We need business people, like the Commissioners who know what's required. We have to bear the pain at the moment to get the gain. You can't undo years of handsitting in 5 mins and for $10.


GET ON WITH IT

Posted on 14-11-2023 16:35 | By fair game

Drove through the city during the week, took about 45 minutes to drive 5 kms. Astounded at the number of road workers just leaning on shovels, vaping, and having a good old yarn instead of working. Should be working 24 hours per day in 8 hour shifts and actually working, not playing with hi vis vests on. Do they ever get audited? Can't believe we're paying these numpties to do minimal work.


Recognise the hardship

Posted on 14-11-2023 18:46 | By Watchdog

Businesses big and small have been facing hardship with all the rework being carried out. Its not just days of downward sales, it has been months and businesses are moving out. What is need is significant financial compensation to affected businesses who can show (probably quite easily) that their business is suffering. Maybe $10million split up amongst the affected shop-owners. It's small bikkies compared to the $300 million in the Civic Centre build. It might help keep shops operating and possibly even bring some back who have closed up for the duration of the works.
What is the most important thing in all the world? - it is people, it is people, it is people!! Look after them!


@Artemis & WestieMum

Posted on 15-11-2023 11:52 | By morepork

I agree that 10B's Council needed to go, and some of your criticisms are well founded. But the MAJOR problem with the Commission is that they are NOT answerable to anybody, and, because they were government appointed, they seek to implement a since failed and changed government's policy. There is no engagement with the community because they never listen and they believe they are infallible. We are ruled by an unelected elite who have established a very nice gravy train for themselves and their cronies, and we have no recourse. Saying they are "business people" so they know what they are doing, is like saying that Donald Trump (who is also a "business person") is an ideal person to manage the most powerful nation on Earth... Administrators who are being given authority over Other People's Money, NEED to be responsible, transparent, and ANSWERABLE. This Commission MUST go!


@Watchdog

Posted on 15-11-2023 12:03 | By morepork

Of course, you are right; our city and our community is comprised of people. We need to look after each other, and seeing the hardship imposed on local businesses without any move to offer even a Rates Holiday, is pretty disappointing. Destroying our businesses is bad, but the actions of this Commission affects all of us. Whether you're a young person trying to get to work, a pensioner who has to go shopping on the bus, a Mum who has to collect and deliver kids, in fact, ANYONE who has to leave home at some point, you will be subject to the effects and stress imposed on our city by the grandiose and ill-affordable visions of our unelected and unanswerable administration. The sooner it is over, the better for all of us.


Curly's video.

Posted on 15-11-2023 12:12 | By morepork

I watched it on YouTube. It is really very good and very fair. He is an unbiased observer who WANTS to love our City (he seems to make friends easily and he liked the Tauranga people) but he cannot ignore the facts... the CBD is mostly deserted and the businesses still there are hanging on by the skin of their teeth. When you see it from his point of view, you see a really beautiful place where it should be easy to be and it should be thriving. (I remember it that way, so I know it is POSSIBLE...) The fault is not with the location, the resources, or the people; it is with the Management... We need to fix it, and start by removing the Commission... I hope Sam is working on it.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.