Research shows the existing tolls - on just three highways - are low by international standards, at under $3 a trip.
The new government policy statement on land transport out on Monday puts more tolling firmly on the table.
It's a draft, and officials now have three months to report back on how to do it.
"The NZTA should consider tolling to construct and maintain all new roads, including the roads of national significance," the draft says.
"The Government will support all recommendations by NZTA to toll roads."
One barrier was that the current tolling system was highly inefficient, swallowing a third of revenue just to run it.
NZTA Waka Kotahi is deep into a $40m contract with a Spanish company to replace it. The agency did not respond to requests for an update on the project.
Scott Wilson, of Milestone Solutions NZ, foresees more tolls within two-to-three years.
He says they might work on nine out of the new 15 roads of national significance projects also announced on Monday.
For a toll to work, a road must have few entry and exit points and there must be a alternative free route. The ones that are "motorway oriented" are best suited, says Wilson.
Mill Road - an on-again-off-again south Auckland four-laner - is not well suited, he says.
"Ōtaki-Levin might be suited to it, but the problem there is that that road is designed to take a lot of traffic off of a relatively unsafe existing road."
Tricky choosing which roads work for tolls
"It's going to depend upon the cost of installing tolling and the volumes of traffic to be able to recover enough revenue to make it worthwhile, and whether the travel-time savings that those roads generate are sufficiently worthwhile that people are going to willing to pay a toll," says Wilson.
Infrastructure Commission lead economist Peter Nunns says the Northern Gateway Orewa to Pūhoi toll works because it saves a decent swag of time and is a nicer safer driver.
The toll for cars is just $2.60 - the only two other tolls are even lower.
"The tolls we've levied on them have covered a portion of the cost of the road, not the entire cost of the road," says Nunns.
"And the question going forward in an environment in which the cost to build infrastructure project is escalating, is can we actually get to a place where these things are more self funding."
A 2021 study showed tolls here were at just half those in Australia
Nunns said the only way to find out if people would pay more was to try.
Other options
On Wednesday, Nunns attended a meeting of engineers about congestion charging, another user-pays option, which has been accepted in some places where it's used overseas.
The third funding option the government has ordered officials to do more work on, is road user charges for everyone.
Mark Heine heads up Eroad which has the GPS technology that can be put in all vehicles to enable this.
He sounds a note of caution on tolls.
"Tolls can be quite a costly set up, and there's always usually ways to get around tolling in terms of alternative routes," he says.
"So using tolls has only a limited degree of efficacy around only key arterial routes really."
3 comments
Just 3 tolls
Posted on 08-03-2024 09:46 | By an_alias
You forgot Tolley, old Tolls has been spending like no tomorrow, dont forget her.
What a farce of a propoganda piece comparing apples with oranges.
This is a policy of ONLY THE RICH can travel and 15 minute cities.
Nothing more than a TAX grab and you have the audacity to present it like this.
Oh boy and get the opinion of EROAD who will make money on GPS tracking....just WOW
Do it
Posted on 08-03-2024 13:03 | By First Responder
Ever been around Europe? Toll plazas are common and have led to great roads, with 130kph speed limits. Imagine if we had a dual carriageway under the kaimais. I bet most would happily pay $20. Some toll booths overseas charge $70 for a truck and trailer, and they cruise on flat roads at 110kph. Bring on good roads, and who cares about tolls. Get with the modern age.
Real roads
Posted on 08-03-2024 17:40 | By Duegatti
I've driven on quite a few Italian toll roads. What you get for what is a fair amount of money is well maintained, high speed, multilane roads shared with drivers who can drive.
The antithesis of NZ toll roads.
We drove 450 kms from Vicenza to Rapallo in 4 hours including a short stop for a snack and refuel.
Here we have the Takitimu Dr farce. $1.90 to drive a few kms on a bumpy, mostly single lane joke of a highway.
I'm happy to pay tolls if you get value for money.
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.