'Corrosive obsession with race'-ACT on Maori wards

ACT Party leader David Seymour said his party opposes Māori Wards. Photo: Supplied.

ACT Party leader David Seymour would vote against Māori wards if his home council were to hold a referendum on them.

The party opposed Māori Wards, but Seymour “accepts that, it should be up to local people by referendum to decide if they want them”.

“If there was a vote in Auckland where I reside, I'd be voting no.”

The Government plans to require councils to hold a binding referendum on Māori wards established after March 2021.

During a visit to Tauranga on Thursday, Seymour spoke to Local Democracy Reporting about the issue. 

“Our [ACT’s] basic view is that human beings are wonderful, filled with different characteristics, particularly their skills and their hopes and dreams, their challenges.

“Yet for some reason there's been a really corrosive obsession in New Zealand with a person's race.”

Asked if there was any harm in ensuring Māori were represented on councils, Seymour replied: “New Zealand is made up of people from all walks of life.

“The one thing they've all got in common is either they or their ancestors moved here for a better tomorrow.

“It’s not really obvious why some people's background is more important than others.

“I'm not really sure why we take a period of time 200 years ago and decide to privilege some humans over others.”

Some of the crowd at a meeting organised by the Concerned Citizens group about Māori wards in Tauranga in 2021. File photo/SunLive. 

Māori wards in Tauranga and the Western Bay of Plenty could be affected by the Government's new policy.

Tauranga City Council will have a Māori ward for the first time at the upcoming election on July 20.

The decision was made to establish one in 2020, but this was nearly overturned by a petition from a group called Concerned Citizens.

This was done through a legal loophole where if a petition was signed by of at least 5 per cent of the local population, they could overturn a council's decision on Māori wards by forcing a binding referendum on the matter.

Local government minister at the time Nanaia Mahuta enabled the Local Electoral (Māori Wards and Māori Constituencies) Amendment Bill, preventing such petitions from affecting future council decisions on Māori wards.

The commission confirmed the previous council’s decision on Māori wards at meeting in April 2021.

It was described as a “momentous day” on August 17, 2023, when the Western Bay of Plenty District Council voted to establish a Māori ward after mana whenua campaigned for over a decade.

Western Bay of Plenty will need to hold a poll on Māori wards at the 2025 election. No action will be needed for Tauranga in the July election, but the council will need to consider it before its next election in 2028.

 Local Government New Zealand president Sam Broughton said the decision about Māori wards should be made at a council level. Photo: Supplied.

Local Government New Zealand president Sam Broughton labelled the government’s decision a “complete overreach”.

“The Coalition Government is removing decision-making from councils by mandating polls be run on Māori wards and constituencies alone,” Broughton said in a statement.

“We have long asked that Māori wards and constituencies be treated like all other wards and the decisions be made at the council level. 

“Currently, councils can make decisions about the establishment of Māori wards and constituencies for themselves. No one is forced, it’s a choice by communities’ elected representatives.

“Councils make these decisions based on feedback from their communities and iwi representatives.”

When announcing the decision, Local Government Minister Simeon Brown said any decision to establish or disestablish a Māori ward should remain with communities.

"This does not affect councils’ responsibilities to consult with mana whenua on issues that affect them.”

The government would introduce a bill in the coming months requiring councils to hold a referendum alongside the 2025 election. The results would be binding and come into effect at the 2028 local government elections.

Any council not wanting to hold a poll would be given the opportunity to reverse their decision or disestablish Māori wards prior to the 2025 local body elections.

LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.

4 comments

The question is...

Posted on 13-04-2024 12:55 | By morepork

...does a Maori Ward serve any practical purpose that ISN'T being served by local government, or is the attraction for Maori just an emotional one, connected with mana and "identity"? The last 30 years (in particular) have seen rapid growth in both Maori and non-Maori communities. Today's Maori youth are attending University, starting their own businesses and proving to be as capable in every way as non-Maori. There is less need (IMO) for Maori seats and wards in order to protect Maori interests, because Maori are more than capable of using the same mechanisms as everybody else to protect their interests. Instead, these institutions become divisive and controversial, especially if they are seen to give advantages that other sectors of the community cannot have. The basis of all Racism is perceived disparity between ethnic groups. Democracy requires community approval for special groups and treatment.


I 'd like to see...

Posted on 13-04-2024 13:05 | By morepork

... supporters of Maori Wards giving reasons WHY they think they are still necessary. I'm on the fence; persuade me. Also, if local government is NOT meeting special Maori (or any other ethnicity's...) needs, then let's address and fix that. There has to be a level playing field if we are to advance together as a nation. And it's time we stopped trying to dominate one another and started working together for the good of ALL our communities. Kiwis who need help, should get it, and it shouldn't depend on who your ancestors were, who you know, the colour of your skin, or any other prejudicial attribute.


Absolutely....

Posted on 14-04-2024 12:28 | By groutby

... morepork...agree 100%...100%.!


Referenda

Posted on 15-04-2024 14:56 | By Kancho

Yep being on a binding referendum. If there is merit in what appears to be a duplication . We are multicultural and anyone can stand on their own merits not a special case . Seems we have a museum (s) regardless of referenda so is this going to be the same ?


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.