Ex-detective: Child abuse statistics “appalling”

Child Matters CEO Jane Searle. Photo: Christel Yardley/Stuff.

The name suppression lift for a woman jailed for abusing her daughter, leading to her death, is a timely reminder for the need for improved child monitoring in New Zealand, says national child abuse advocacy group Child Matters.

Southern Thompson was previously jailed for life with a minimum non-parole period of 17 years on charges of murder, ill-treatment of a child, injuring her with intent and failing to seek medical care.

Yesterday she gave formal notice to the Court of Appeal that she was abandoning her appeal, meaning her name suppression expired.

Her daughter, Comfort Jay Thompson-Pene, was killed in 2018 and an autopsy concluded she died as the result of head injuries due to blunt force trauma. Comfort was a victim of prolonged abuse, court documents have revealed.

Ex-Police detective, lawyer and now CEO of Child Matters, Jane Searle, says the details of Comfort's case are horrific and serve as a confronting reminder about New Zealand's appalling child abuse statistics and lack of cohesive monitoring for New Zealand's tamariki.

'Unfortunately this type of abuse is happening every day around the country and we don't hear about this until another child dies in tragic circumstances and that story hits the news headlines,” she says.

'We need a system that monitors our children better from the time they are born. In the case of Comfort, she did not have a chance as there was no one taking care of her interests and meeting her needs.”

Searle says that the proposed changes to the Children's Commissioner, through the Oversight of Oranga Tamariki Bill, go completely against the need to improve New Zealand's system to better look after New Zealand's most vulnerable children.

'If anything, positions like the Child's Commissioner need to be better funded and supported, not effectively disestablished and downgraded.

'Many politicians seem to be out of touch with the realities of what is happening in our country. They are pushing ahead with a Bill that essentially dismantles the Office of the Children's Commissioner, against huge opposition from community and frontline organisations.

'This sends a tragic message that the Government is willing to ignore the voice of frontline workers to achieve their own agenda.”

Searle believes the reversal of New Zealand's child abuse statistics require three key elements: the vigilance of local communities; a timely response from Government agencies; and the effective and appropriate resourcing of community specialist services.

She says that should include the introduction of mandatory child protection training for professionals or volunteers who work with children and young people.

On average, one child dies every five weeks at the hands of someone else in New Zealand.

Child Matters is an independent child abuse advocacy and training provider and New Zealand's only national charitable trust dedicated to the prevention of child abuse.

3 comments

So sad

Posted on 07-07-2022 14:24 | By Kancho

The recent local case truly appalling its just heart breaking we have such bad statistics and shame upon our country, that children can be tortured to death. It is also incredible that the government pushes through in spite of widespread criticism and against advice from many quarters including their own ministry's . Seems this is a common thread of government to not listen and go against advice and yet also demonstrated without any success . Except perhaps in growing bureacracy that absorbs any extra funding for the dire need.


Comfort Thompson - Pene

Posted on 07-07-2022 15:58 | By davidt5

We nee a system where the children are monitored by independent people. For the 1st 3 years of life this should be the Plunket Nurse checking in on the child on a fortnightly basis. If the child is not available at the appointed time, Police are notified to check the child and a fee charged for this check. Children aged 3 to 5 should be monitored by staff from the Children's commissioner. If not available Police notified and fee charged. Children aged 5 to 8 should be checked by a nurse employed by the school for this purpose. Children aged over 8 are able to speak up for themselves. With regular monitoring our children / tamariki will be able to live to old age and child abuse reduced to a very minimum. Should children not be made available for checking then the mother should be brought before the Courts.


Counsjan

Posted on 08-07-2022 07:13 | By Counsjan

It appears to me that anything that is working well gets dismantled by Govt. Who is advising them? Orange Tamariki? Their record of success is not startling . They do their best but there needs to be advocacy outside of that arena. Years ago a scheme was developed to develop Child Advocates who were attached to front line community agencies. For the most part this worked well and were good advocates for children but then, in the middle of cases they were advocating for, like the child commissioner, who is the ultimate in advocacy, they were dis-established, leaving a big hole in someone neutral looking out for the kids.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.